© janaka dharmasena / dreamstime.com Application Notes | December 07, 2017
A short history of hybrid & module technology
Why it continues as a packaging technology of choice for high reliability applications.
This is a product release announcement by Linear Technology. The issuer is solely responsible for its content.
Hybrid and module technology has been evolving for more than 50 years and now in the form of COTS (Commercial-Off-The-Shelf) modules is making major contributions to reducing design cycles, mitigating obsolescence and addressing SWaP (Size, Weight and Power) challenges. Let’s take a look back the history of the technology and explore some of the factors that are important to the aerospace and defence industry. Early Hybrids In the late 1950s, advances in computing using discrete transistors made huge strides forward, but circuit boards were becoming increasingly complex, sometimes with thousands of interconnected transistors, diodes, resistors and capacitors. A solution was needed to improve the density and reliability. Government agencies funded various hybrid circuit ideas. The military was especially interested and active in this field. In 1958, the US Army funded RCA to develop their “micro-module” concept. This took the approach of uniform-sized cubes externally configured so that they could be clipped together. Internally, small wafers of the various discrete components were vertically stacked and interconnected at their edges. Component density by volume was more than doubled and reliability increased by a factor of six, which delighted the military who invested further over the coming few years. In 1962, according to an article in Electronic Engineering Times, a 10-component module cost $52, around 2.5 times the cost of a conventional discrete PCB solution. Despite its cost, the RCA micro-module was very successful but short-lived and the birth of the integrated circuit (IC) no doubt contributed to its demise. At nine times the cost of a hybrid solution, early ICs were often the beneficiary of military or government funded programs and one notable 1962 project was the Raytheon-built Apollo Guidance Computer for NASA. With the rapid evolution of ICs, their advantages over hybrids and modules were soon recognized. In that regard, it seems surprising that hybrid circuit technology survived at all. However, the military often had broader considerations, including product stability and long-term availability, reliability, utility versus innovation and complex operational requirements. These factors together with the specific technical advantages of hybrids and modules have undoubtedly contributed to their continued usage over the last 50 years. Integration In the timescale spanned by this article, ASIC technology has revolutionized the industry. Initially, gate arrays of a few hundred gates offered the military a route to improved digital integration and as gate densities rapidly advanced and development tools were refined, the days of the hybrid circuit looked numbered. In the late 1980s, military equipment designers recognizing the success of digital ASICs, attempted to apply the same techniques to mixed-signal circuits. Their motives were dominated by the need for miniaturization, as more and more complex systems were demanded by the military, which had big budgets at that time. But difficulties adapting full custom design tools for customer use and the complexity of analog design, meant that mixed-signal ASIC remained very resource intensive and highly reliant on semiconductor manufacturer design teams for, in effect, full-custom designs. While analog ASIC design tools and technology have made significant progress, the breadth of real-world analog problems are still difficult to implement with off-the-shelf semi-custom circuits. Thus, hybrid circuits have continued to offer a means of integrating various high-performance analog and signal-chain functions of differing process technologies into a single package when off-the-shelf products will not do the job. Performance Military and aerospace systems are generally designed on the basis of modular sub-systems. For example, line replaceable units (LRUs) simplify service and operational support. Interconnecting LRUs rely on standards such as the MIL-STD-1553 bus interface. Implementing these functions in hybrids, modules, ASIC macros or on standard format circuit boards has become the preferred approach and they are, in effect, application specific standard products (ASSPs) and building blocks. This highlights two important factors. First, there is nothing to be gained by re-inventing the wheel and designers are more usefully employed focusing on the core intellectual property of the system. Secondly, the military and aerospace industry is a small user of semiconductors by today’s standards and developing solutions at the module or board level is a more realistic proposition than a monolithic IC-level ASSP. Traditionally, the performance requirements of power supply modules has also aligned well with hybrid module technology where the use of hermetic metal can packaging supports the power density and thermal management needs of high-temperature, high-reliability military applications. With increasing power requirements from large FPGAs and microprocessors, the drive for more efficient power architectures and point-of-load (POL) regulation has given rise to new module solutions. Applications such as radar have also long-relied on hybrids and modules for RF and microwave solutions. Only in recent years have there been monolithic IC products that begin to address some of these needs but now the integration needs of modern highly parallel phased array radars are again focusing attention on module solutions. Security Product obsolescence is an acute problem for the military. A 30- to 50-year program life is commonplace so military and aerospace equipment suppliers are continually looking for ways to mitigate risk. Hybrids and modules have been one approach to try and isolate the defense industry from the rapid pace of change in the semiconductor industry. Memory modules are a specific area of interest because of the particularly short lifecycle of DRAM and SRAM technology. The concept of a standard form factor and pin-out can be maintained, while the memory dice inside the module can be updated. This is a lot easier to write about than it is to do in practice, in part, due to continual advancements in access times, architectures and supply voltages. On another level, the use of standard format embedded processor cards provide an alternative higher-level approach where space permits. However, the notion of standard form factors is central to many obsolescence management strategies and has certainly been a major influencing factor in the long life of hybrid and module solutions. Hybrids and modules is also benefit because a full-custom module can be used to conceal valuable intellectual property related to the hardware design, making it more difficult to reverse engineer. Simply looking at part numbers on packages will not be enough to decode the design hardware. Furthermore, some semiconductor dice are also not readily available on the open market. From Full Custom to Modern Day COTS The previous arguments for continued use of hybrids and modules in military systems remain valid. However, it is important to recognize that the commercial pressures on military equipment manufacturers are greater now than ever before, and in particular, costs and time to market. Full custom hybrid designs are expensive and take a relatively long time to develop. More alternative monolithic IC solutions are becoming available every year. While new hybrid designs are still developed at major defence companies, there is a detectable trend towards out-sourcing manufacture as volumes decline. The picture for COTS modules is quite different. There is definite momentum toward module-based solutions driven by both technical and commercial considerations. Switching power supplies and signal chains are two areas that are particularly well suited to module implementation as efficient designs need specialist knowledge that is a scarce commodity in today’s military design teams. Enter μModule® Products μModule products are an example of modern day COTS modules. Launched by Linear Technology in 2005, one of the first products provided a complete 12A DC/DC regulator in a 15mm square surface mount package (Figure 1). Figure 1. The LTM4601AHV 12A μModule DC/DC Regulator Subsequently, a complete family of μModule products have been developed, including a wide range of power, interface and signal chain products with recently released examples such as the LTM9100 (Figure 2) and ADAQ7980 (Figure 3). Figure 2. The LTM9100, High Voltage Isolated Switch Controller with Telemetry Figure 3. The ADAQ7980 16-bit 1Msps Data Acquisition Subsystem COTS Module Package Styles Resembling a surface mount IC, each μModule regulator includes a complete system-in-a-package solution that simplifies design and minimizes external components. Internally, the layout and design are optimized for electrical performance and thermal efficiency. Built to the industry’s highest standards, these μModule products offer outstanding reliability, approaching that of standard ICs. LGA (Land Grid Array) packaging with gold finish pads and BGA (Ball Grid Array) packaging with SAC305 or SnPb solders are available in various temperature grades. Figure 4. Two μModule Regulators with LGA & BGA Package Styles Where needed, military temperature range versions of μModule products provide guaranteed data sheet performance through 100% electrical testing at ̶55ºC and +125ºC. Conclusions Fifty years ago, hybrids and modules were a technology of choice to miniaturize electronic circuits and improve their reliability. As the semiconductor industry became commoditized and product lifecycles diverged from those of the defence industry, hybrids and modules found a new role in obsolescence mitigation. While ASIC became the preferred approach for integration of digital electronics, the hybrid module found a niche solving difficult analog problems. Meanwhile COTS modules have emerged in the form of Application Specific Standard Products, notably for power supplies, processors, signal chains and interfaces. These have been widely adopted as military equipment providers react to a new competitive age and recognize the importance of focusing scarce design resources on core competencies. Today, defense budget pressures and shorter design cycles may make full custom hybrids increasingly a legacy solution, but without a doubt, COTS modules are increasingly becoming a technology of choice for the military and aerospace industry.
Author: Steve Munns, Mil-Aero Marketing Manager © Analog Devices Inc. (previously Linear Technology)
Author: Steve Munns, Mil-Aero Marketing Manager © Analog Devices Inc. (previously Linear Technology)
Company veteran takes the helm at Avnet a Distributor Avnet has named 37-year Avnet veteran Phil Gallagher as its new Chief Executive Officer, effective immediately.
Labour dispute at ST France – the conflict continues The strike at STMicroelectronics French operations continues. For the last four weeks, the site in Crolles has been on an indefinite strike following the company’s decision not to increase employee salaries this year.
Tachyum resumes hiring in Slovakia and USA Following a short halt due to COVID-19, the Silicon Valley and Slovakian semiconductor company says that it is restarting its hiring activities.
Intel CEO pens open letter to President-elect Biden Intel CEO Bob Swan is, in an open letter, urging the President-elect to invest in U.S. manufacturing.
Sponsored content by VECTOR BLUE HUBDesign and manufacturing - services under one roof a Today Electronics Manufacturing Services (EMS) companies need to respond with a services that deliver real value to the customer and invest their money wisely. Keeping the services under one roof represents a smart approach, where the customer benefits by being served better, faster and cost effective.
Wafer acpacity by feature size shows strongest growth at <10nm IC capacity for leading-edge (<10nm) processes is expected to grow and become the largest portion of monthly installed capacity across the industry beginning in 2024, based on information in IC Insights’ Global Wafer Capacity 2020-2024 report.
Powell Electronics now Europe’s largest Positronic stockist Powell Electronics, the supplier of connectors and more for high-rel applications, is to become Europe’s largest stocking distributor of Positronic connectors following a franchise deal signed by the two companies.
Alps Alpine develops, starts shipping samples of HAPTIC Reactor Heavy Type Alps Alpine Co., Ltd. has developed the HAPTIC™ Reactor Heavy Type for powerful vibrations in touch feedback. Sample shipments, destined primarily for the automotive market, begin in October 2020, with a start to mass production expected in January 2021.
SkyWater and Multibeam form partnership to deploy Multibeam’s Innovative MEBL system Maskless lithography technology company, Multibeam Corporation, has disclosed a partnership to deploy Multibeam’s Multicolumn Electron-Beam Lithography (MEBL) system into SkyWater’s newly expanded fabrication facility in support the company roadmap to advance its manufacturing capabilities and accelerate growth.
Sponsored content by CMLHow Prepared Are You for Geometric Dimensioning & Tolerance? a One of the biggest challenges that PCB manufacturers face, though it may seem simple but is often overlooked: missing essential information that describes the product. The purpose of PCB drawings is to visualize the representation of a product completely and precisely for production. The PCB drawings today appear more like mechanical drawings for engines rather than for electronic components. Changing a drawing is not a big problem, but to change it when it is already released in production, can create considerable extra expenditures due to delay in production and wrong material selection. However, these problems can be easily avoided.
Intel to keep its number One in 2020 Seven top-15 semiconductor suppliers forecast to show ≥22% growth this year with Nvidia expected to post a huge 50% increase, writes market researcher IC Insights in their latest report.
Trina Solar buys 1.2B units of 210mm monocrystal silicon wafers from Zhonghuan On 19 November 2020, Changzhou Trina Solar Energy and Tianjin Zhonghuan Semiconducto, signed a framework contract. Under the contract, Trina Solar intends to purchase 210mm monocrystal silicon wafers from Tianjin Huanou International Silicon Material Co., Ltd., a Zhonghuan subsidiary.
Kontron Industrial AI Platform for easy integration of Artificial Intelligence The Kontron Industrial AI Platform accelerates the use of AI algorithms for inference in industrial environments, such as quality control or predictive maintenance.
Luminar accelerates momentum with MobilEye design win Automotive lidar hardware and software supplier, Luminar Technologies, has struck a deal with Intel company, Mobileye, to supply Luminar lidar for the company’s Autonomous Vehicle (AV) Series solution in its next phase of driverless car development and testing.
Sponsored content by Würth Elektronik eiSosWürth Elektronik Virtual Conference WE meet @ digital days 2020 a From 1st to 3rd of December (each from 8 am to 6 pm) Würth Elektronik organizes the virtual conference "WE meet @ digital days 2020" with an extensive program of comprehensive technical presentations. The virtual conference offers technical and technology presentations on applications and design-in support - all with an interactive question-and-answer part. In addition, experts from the component manufacturer will be presenting many new products from the Passive & Electromechanical Components, Power Modules & Optoelectronics, Automotive, Frequency Products and Wireless Connectivity & Sensors divisions in English live presentations. Those interested can find the program and free registration for the three-day online forum at www.we-online.com/digital-days. The sessions can be attended individually.
Farnell boosts safety and hygiene portfolio with AMETEK Land AMETEK Land boasts a comprehensive range of non-contact temperature monitors and analysers including the new VIRALERT 3 Human Body Temperature Screening System for back-to-work safety checks.
SK hynix & Robert Bosch invests in memory startup Ferroelectric Memory GmbH (FMC), a developer of ferroelectric hafnium oxide memory technology, has completed a USD 20 million Series B funding.
Synopsys acquires precision optical measurements provider Synopsys has acquired Light Tec, a provider of optical scattering measurements and measurement equipment.
TSMC gets 'OK' in Phoenix City officials in Phoenix, Arizona, authorised a development agreement with chipmaker Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing.
North American semi equipment industry show strong results in October North America-based manufacturers of semiconductor equipment posted USD 2.64 billion in billings worldwide in October 2020 (three-month average basis), according to SEMI.
Camtek receives over $20M in orders for inspection & metrology systems The company says that the orders come from several different manufacturers and that the orders reinforces the outlook for the first half of 2021.
A2 Global Electronics achieves AS9120 quality certification A2 Global Electronics + Solutions, the combined company of America II and Advanced MP, has received the AS9120 Rev B quality management system certification from the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE).
Samsung Semiconductor Europe completes relocation to new office With its new EMEA HQ in Munich, Samsung Semiconductor Europe aims to bring the company closer to key customers and tech talent in the area.Load more news