© coffee_b / dreamstime.com Electronics Production | January 27, 2012
Couples Therapy 101 for OEMs
The OEM-EMS relationship is often characterized as dysfunctional, inequitable, or broken, plus a few other choice terms that cannot be put in print.
These characterizations might make for colorful discussions over drinks at an industry conference, but they do not tell us much about what is actually going wrong in the relationship. Fixing a relationship first requires a better understanding of the actual behaviors/dynamics that are causing the problem. We therefore asked EMS companies a simple, but potentially revealing question: What are the most irritating behaviors exhibited by your OEM customers during either the sales/quoting process or the actual engagement? Several dozen brave individuals responded after receiving guarantees of confidentiality and promises of retraining and entry into the Witness Protection Program if they were discovered by their OEM customers as having participated. Their responses proved very illuminating yet difficult to categorize due to the varied nature of the responses. Let’s therefore look at the data in the two general phases that were asked about: quoting and the actual engagement. NOTE: These survey results are not intended to represent all problematic issues in the OEM-EMS relationship, just those reported by our respondents. I am sure others exist. The Quoting Phase: The main issues mentioned as occurring during the quoting phase centered on: -Data -Money -The vetting process -OEM gamesmanship DATA: In order to produce a quote an EMS actually requires data. This data sits in two related buckets: data about the actual build being requested by the OEM, and data about the business engagement with the specific OEM. Surprisingly, (or maybe not) the lack of complete information needed to quote was the most frequently mentioned issue in the entire survey (38% of respondents). Respondents reported that incomplete, outdated, poor quality, and/or inaccurate data is often provided by OEM customers… yet the OEM still expects an accurate quote. This is akin to asking someone to quote a price for building you a new home without providing number of bedrooms, style or square footage…and expecting a good price with a perfect outcome. Not gonna happen! Regarding the actual terms of engagement that the OEM is asking the EMS to enter into with them, 13% of our respondents reported that OEMs often fail to share strategic data such as forecasts or their Terms & Conditions (T’s & C’s) that would allow the EMS to assess whether they even wish to engage with the particular OEM. This consideration is important for the EMS and definitely influences the mark-up they would choose to apply in their quote. MONEY: Whether you call it cost, pricing, or fee for service, money is always an issue in both the quoting and engagement phases. 29% of respondents reported concerns with OEMs that were most interested in “nickel and diming” them up front, and then insisting on continued “cost downs” or free services throughout the engagement. THE VETTING PROCESS: Many respondents (33%) cited issues with the engagement process that OEMs force upon EMS. To begin, the vetting process is considered too long, involving multiple and sometimes repeated quoting exercises when the OEM is often only trying to get a benchmark so they can squeeze their existing supplier. Several respondents also reported that after a lengthy vetting process the OEM had actually disqualified them for not having a facility in a low cost region, a fact that was apparent at the outset of the process. Many respondents also reported irritation at the “hurry up and wait” attitude wherein OEMs expect quick responses from the EMS while the OEM themselves are slow to respond to the EMS requests for further data and needed clarifications. OEM GAMESMANSHIP: Business is all about winning and gaining advantage, but a fair number of respondents (21%) cited OEM behaviors that they found especially irritating. These included: - Overstating the size of the opportunity or using unrealistic forecasts to get a lower price. - Expecting certain services (e.g., testing), but leaving them out of the RFQ. - Quoting only for benchmarking purposes. - Requesting repeated quotes on the same BOM. EMS companies have limited resources and would prefer to engage in quoting activities only if they have a real chance of winning the business and being allowed to earn a decent return. The Engagement Phase: The main issues mentioned as occurring during the engagement phase centered on: - Materials - Changes - OEM manufacturing support MATERIALS: As in any for-profit enterprise, the EMS industry achieves its gross-margin by applying a mark-up to the underlying elements of Cost of Goods Sold which includes Labor, Overhead and Materials. OEMs try to save money and defer liability to their EMS partners in this area. So it is not surprising that this would be a sensitive area for our EMS respondents. A large proportion of our respondents (28%) cited concerns with OEMs in this area. The main issues were: disagreement over component liability, disagreement over lead times, and receiving insufficient and/or bad parts when the OEM is kitting material to the EMS. These issues result in the EMS having to devote more time trying to negotiate and resolve the challenges. And time, as they say, is money. CHANGES: Electronics manufacturing is often portrayed as a perfectly rational, linear process, but in reality it is always changing based primarily on OEM actions. 15% of respondents cited OEM actions such as: changing their requirements between the quoting and engagement phases; changing or cancelling orders with little notice and with an “oblivious attitude to the impact of the changes on the EMS”; and shortening their delivery expectations once the engagement begins. OEM MANUFACTURING SUPPORT: 18% of respondents cited issues with the oversight provided by OEMs during the engagement that caused them problems. The majority of these related to the perceived lack of manufacturing knowledge that their OEM customers possess. The other respondents commented on issues of OEM internal disconnects that made satisfying their requirements more challenging. This included different objectives between manufacturing and quality, and between purchasing and engineering especially in regards to changes in specifications. What Does It Mean? Based on these results, some OEMs do not need a manufacturing partner…they need a magician. Good relationships require two basic ingredients: good communications and honesty. Consistency in these areas allows trust to develop. If an OEM is interested in having their EMS perform optimally, then they must acknowledge and address the behaviors that are hindering performance. After decades of over-capacity in the contract manufacturing services industry, and companies like Foxconn stealing market share through questionable business practices, it isn't surprising that OEMs have gotten used to a master-slave type relationship with their EMS. However, the times are changing. With the continuing consolidation and shrinkage in the industry, and a substantial number of EMS and ODM companies exiting the services business model altogether, it might be worthwhile for OEMs to consider taking a closer look at this relationship. A good place to start might be asking your EMS suppliers the same question that we posed in our survey. ----- Author: Eric Miscoll
Second install for EFI at Mid America Display Silicon Valley’s EFI will install a second EFI Nozomi C18000 single-pass inkjet, direct-to-board printer later this month to Mid America Display.
Ron Jakeman of Electrolube looks back at a successful 2019 Electrolube has been growing, both in terms of its footprint and financially, for a number of years not; Ron Jakeman details the company's progress.
Etteplan and Scanfil to start strategic cooperation in joint customer projects Engineering company Etteplan and contract manufacturer Scanfil have today agreed to enter a strategic partnership in Finland.
The lovechild of ACE Production and InterSelect Carlos Bouras of Nordson Select gave us the rundown of the result of the integration and combination of ACE Production and InterSelect GmbH - the new Integra.
Sponsored content by NCAB Group Benelux B.V.Failure is not an option for a PCB More than 30% of the Gerbers NCAB Group Benelux B.V. reviews, have problems. However, the PCB are integrated in key end-user product with more and more High Tech PCB. We are here to support you on the new technologies growth to maintain a high reliability and quality. Contact us to review it together.
American Battery Metals, U.S. lawmakers convene American Battery Metals Corporation has completed a series of meetings with lawmakers and personnel in the Department of Energy and Department of the Interior in Washington, D.C., to discuss issues critical to the domestic battery production and storage industry.
Cogiscan, Critical Mfg. form strategic partnership Quebec, Canada-based Cogiscan and Critical Manufacturing, headquartered in Portugal, have forged a strategic partnership to deliver smart factory solutions for electronics manufacturers.
Collins Aerospace expanding in North Africa Collins Aerospace Systems, a unit of United Technologies Corp., has taken the first step toward the expansion of its existing site in Casablanca, Morocco.
The advantage of Vantage - Garrett Wong tells the tale Nordson Asymtek's Garrett Wong gives us a rundown of the business year and also details the Vantage Advantage
Saki’s Eddie Ichiyama details a very successful business year Eddie ichiyama from Saki gave us an update on how 2019 has been for the company and also shared some details on the recent expansion in the Czech Republic.
The ripple effect of Enrico Krog Iversen while being an active part in creating one of the fastest growing robotics companies in modern time might have been enough for most people, that does not seem to have slowed down a certain Danish entrepreneur.
Yamaha's Ichiro Arimoto on the business year and the company's new ventures Evertiq had the opportunity to talk to Ichiro Arimoto, General Manager of Yamaha Motor Europe, about the business year and the company's new ventures.
Mycronic, Indium forge strategic partnership Indium Corporation has announced a strategic partnership with Sweden-based Mycronic, to develop no-clean and water soluble solder pastes for jetting applications.
Sponsored content by Nordson ASYMTEKStart-to-finish conformal coating with reliability and efficiency Nordson ASYMTEK’s flexible, modular, Panorama™ S-Line delivers conformal coating process control in a space-saving footprint with overlapping line processes that minimize manufacturing floor space. This innovative, patent-pending line layout trims 50% of the line’s length by using the lower compartment in each piece of equipment for functional use. Combined with Nordson ASYMTEK’s global support, this complete conformal coating line delivers quality, product reliability, efficiency, and safety for all your conformal coating applications.
SCHMID delivers PlasmaLine to Hofstetter PCB SCHMID announced it has installed the company’s first PlasmaLine comprising ICP etch & sputter deposition of its Korean JV SCHMID AVACO at Hofstetter PCB AG in Switzerland.
Cobot market to reach USD 9+ billion by 2025 A new report from Tractica is forecasting continued rapid growth for the global collaborative robot (cobot) market over the next few years, reaching revenue of USD 9.7 billion by 2025.
MixComm scores USD 8+ million in series B round New Jersey-based fabless semiconductor company MixComm has secured USD 8.6 million in series B funding led by existing investor, Kairos Ventures.
SIA elects 2020 leadership The Semiconductor Industry Association (SIA) Board of Directors has elected ON Semiconductor CEO Keith Jackson as its 2020 Chair and Qorvo CEO Robert Bruggeworth as its 2020 Vice Chair.
Sponsored content by SourcengineComponent Aggregators vs E-Commerce Marketplaces What is the difference between electronic component aggregators and a marketplace?
67% of a buyer’s journey is now done digitally. Learn how marketplaces emerged as full-cycle procurement platforms and challenged the traditional component aggregators.
Si wafer shipments recede for fourth straight quarter Worldwide silicon wafer area shipments slid for the fourth consecutive quarter of 2019, according to the SEMI Silicon Manufacturers Group (SMG) in its most recent quarterly analysis of the industry.
Decline in Q4 DRAM contract prices lessens as buying momentum recovers According to the latest analysis from the DRAMeXchange research division of TrendForce, Q4 DRAM ASP is as of yet undergoing a slight QoQ decline, but this decline has shrunk down to 5%.
Technica forms growth-focused equity fund San Jose-based Technica USA has reached an agreement on an equity investment centered on future growth for the global PCB fab and assembly supplier.
IHS Markit: 5G economy in the trillions by 2035 The IHS Markit 5G Economy Study, commissioned by Qualcomm Technologies Inc., is forecasting that 5G will generate USD 13.2 trillion in sales enablement by 2035.
Sponsored content by EsemdaContract manufacturer Esemda opens new facility in Vilnius and expands EMS The new facility has been built with reserved space for future expansions. As Esemda constantly grows, it is of great importance to be able to rapidly increase production capacity in large volumes.
ZEUS Battery partnering with Kruvand Associates ZEUS Battery Products and Texas-based Kruvand Associates Inc. have come to a formal agreement on a collaboration that began in January and covers Texas, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Louisiana, New Mexico, Arizona and Mexico.
EPP with a new owner The company announces that is has found itself an ideal buyer – Photonics Systems Group – a manufacturer of micro-materials processing machines. With this takeover, PSG is strengthening is operations in the electronics industry and also laying the foundation for further growth.
Volkswagen starts pre-production e-mobility plant in China The new plant of the SAIC VOLKSWAGEN joint venture has been completed. It is purely built for the production of all electric vehicles on Volkswagen’s Modular Electric Drive Matrix (MEB).
Kongsberg Maritime divests KM Contros GmbH Following a strategic review, Kongsberg Maritime AS (KM) has decided to divest KM Contros GmbH (Contros) to AML Oceanographic Ltd. (AML).Load more news