Electronics Production | July 30, 2010
Could Foxconn Fail?
Having spent time at O’Hare airport in Chicago recently, I noticed several billboards advertising Accenture consulting services. One is a photo of an elephant skillfully maneuvering a wicked wave on a surfboard. I think it might be digitally enhanced.
The tagline is, “Who says you can’t be big and nimble?” This was a replacement for the Tiger Woods campaign, after Accenture dropped him due to his difficulties, so it might have been thrown together, but I don’t think it’s very effective. Consultants have been accused of not having a good handle on the basic laws of nature, and this seems to me a very good example of that weakness. Elephants can’t surf. I think there are some lessons to be learned here. In choosing to outsource manufacturing to companies in countries with cheap labor, electronics industry decision-makers have, sometimes unwittingly, added substantial risk to their business. Now, calculating the cost and responding to the consequences of that risk is part of the job description of every OEM operations manager, even those that have no substantial operations in China. In recent years the EMS Tier structure has changed dramatically. A few companies, with Foxconn way out in front, have gobbled up the majority of the EMS pie. Seven companies with operations in China – CBA calls them the China Syndrome Seven – have engaged in predatory pricing and thereby now dominate the majority of global outsourcing. This dominance, in turn, has enabled them to exert a stranglehold on the supply chain, which has created severe parts shortages during recent months for everyone else. Anyone having trouble getting tantalum capacitors? The China Syndrome Seven have the supply chain locked up. This stark reality is an example of how this situation impacts all electronics manufacturing in every industry. The size and scale of these China Syndrome enterprises, especially Foxconn, is beyond the industry’s experience curve. While top line growth is seemingly unstoppable due to the global demand for electronic wizardry, the health of these companies’ bottom lines is completely dependent on artificially low labor rates and on the complex and opaque supply chain contracts they negotiate through dominance. The resulting global interconnectedness of the electronics manufacturing industry, along with the sheer size of these operations and their lack of transparency, is what creates the risk. The conventional wisdom has always held that the supply of cheap labor in China is a bottomless reservoir, but there are signs that managing it may be far more difficult and unpredictable than most electronics manufacturers anticipated. For example, Foxconn has announced it is moving its Shenzhen factory inland in response to the global outrage over worker suicides. Imagine the logistics of completing that task on a human level, while continuing to satisfy Steve Jobs’ iPhone marketing juggernaut. It could take a few months to move or replace 300,000 workers, don’t you think? That's like a refugee situation. Is it really possible to do that and still build millions of iPads and iPhone 4’s? The recent hardware issues in Apple products seem to indicate not. Will demand fluctuate substantially when Apple fans become dissatisfied? Will there be panic in Cupertino? Foxconn’s success surely results from military-like control over all aspects of its employees and operations. Is that sustainable in the Internet age? So we have to ask ourselves, could Foxconn collapse? If it does, how would that impact your business? Foxconn represents nearly US$90 billion of electronics manufacturing capacity. What if a portion of that goes completely offline, even if for only a few months? Like a sudden shortage in any part of the global marketplace, there will be some ‘scrambling’ and panic to capture capacity – both from Foxconn and its competitors. What does that mean to your product’s manufacturing schedule? There isn’t enough capacity left in the world to replace US$90 billion quickly. Many industries are dependent on Foxconn’s customers’ products. With the global economy so fragile, what kind of ripple effect would its unraveling create? Failure tends to happen because of small inconsequential events that cascade into catastrophe. Seldom is it one single cause, and the situation is typically fine – until it suddenly just isn’t. Industry ‘experts’ and pundits may continue to tell us that elephants can surf, but perhaps we should spend time figuring out what to do in case they can’t. An elephant falling off a surfboard can create quite a big splash. Knowledge, as always, is power. ----- Author: Jennifer Read, Charlie Barnhart & Associates
Schurter Romania certified to IATF 16949 On 25 November 2019, the Schurter Electronic Components s.r.l. production site in Ilfov, Romania, received the audit certificate according to the automotive standard IATF 16949:2016.
AQ Group appoints new CFO Christina Hegg has been appointed new CFO for AQ Group. She will start her new position in April 2020 and will be a member of Group Management.
Ventec invests in expansion of PTFE laminates manufacturing Ventec International has significantly increased its PTFE laminate manufacturing capabilities following a strategic investment in a new high-temperature press and lay-up/break-down line at its Suzhou (China) manufacturing plant.
Mitsubishi Electric Power Products to sell its Memphis factory Mitsubishi Electric Power Products, Inc. (MEPPI) has entered into an agreement to sell its power transformer factory located in Memphis, Tennessee to Hyosung Heavy Industries, known for the HICO brand in the United States.
Sponsored content by CMLCML putting the drive into e-mobility As the global demand and trend for e-mobility grows, we understand that customers are looking for products with better performance, stricter tolerance, increased reliability and cost effectiveness. This means your PCB provider must understand the challenge you are facing, be able to support you throughout the whole process – from the first technical questions to the end of life.
MRSI moves to new facility MRSI Systems, which was acquired by Mycronic back in 2018, is moving to its new 102,000 square-foot facility in Tewksbury, Massachusetts.
dSPACE adds West Coast office Simulation and validation specialist dSPACE has opened a Silicon Valley office in San Jose, California as part of its strategic realignment.
Cogiscan, BasiCAE form strategic partnership Quebec-based Cogiscan Inc. has announced a partnership with China’s BasiCAE Technology, a provider of traditional shop control systems and software customization services.
Korea hits new record of industrial robots in operation The World Robotics report presented by the International Federation of Robotics (IFR) shows a new record stock of about 300,000 operational industrial robots in the Republic of Korea in 2018 (+10%).
Keytronic starts production at its new Vietnam facility Keytronic Corporation says it has started shipping product from its new Da Nang, Vietnam manufacturing facility.
USI's looking to accelerate expansion - acquires Asteelflash It looks like we’re ending 2019 with a bang. One of the worlds biggest EMS providers wants to acquire one of Europe’s largest electronics manufacturers.
Devon manufacturer adds capabilities in Dorset via acqusition Devon-based PCB manufacturer, EuroTech Group, is acquiring PCB manufacturer Lyncolec, based in Poole, Dorset.
Kyocera and TactoTek collaborate on IMSE solution Kyocera and TactoTek has singed a marketing agreement which aims to bring IMSE solutions to several new market segments, including industrial and automotive components, electronic devices, and more.
IPC: Unanimous approval of USMCA needed IPC issued a statement this week expressing support of the recently bi-partisan approval of the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), and a strong desire for legislative approval by Canada, Mexico, and the U.S.
Nordson's CFO to retire in 2020 after 30 years with the company Nordson's Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Gregory A. Thaxton, plans to retire in 2020 after thirty successful years with the company, with the last 12 years as CFO.
KUKA restructures subdivision due to economic uncertainty KUKA is restructuring a subdivision in the Robotics segment that is responsible for automated manufacturing solutions such as cells and special machines.
PCB industry recovers slightly in Q3 PCB manufacturers in the D/A/CH region were able to increase sales sequentially in the third quarter of 2019 by 1.1%. However, sales figures are 11% lower than those recorded for the third quarter of 2018, reports the industry association ZVEI PCB and Electronic Systems.
Garz & Fricke moves into new HQ in Hamburg-Harburg Garz & Fricke GmbH continues to expand. As of late October, the business operations of the HMI and Panel PC specialist will be transferring to the new headquarters in in Hamburg-Harburg.
TF Massif Technologies taps new CEO British Columbia-based TF Massif Technologies has announced the appointment of Tom Peregoodoff as the company’s new chief executive officer.
DoJ: Google, Fitbit deal under review The U.S. Justice Department is looking into anti-trust issues concerning Google's bid to buy Fitbit Inc.
L3Harris Tech secures U.S. Marine Corps order L3Harris Technologies received a USD 50 million follow-on delivery order for Falcon III AN/PRC-160 HF radios and related equipment from the U.S. Marine Corps .
Metair completes Romanian lithium-Ion battery cell factory South African energy storage company, Metair Investments, says that its Romanian units Prime Batteries and Rombat have completed the installation of the group's first Lithium-Ion battery cell manufacturing and assembly facility in Bucharest, Romania.
£5m award marks ‘topping out’ of Cardiff research powerhouse An GBP 80 million Cardiff University powerhouse for Welsh scientific research has been ‘topped out’ by Bouygues UK – backed by over GBP5 million support from Welsh Government and industrial partners.
Advanced Energy expands with new lab near Frankfurt Advanced Energy Industries, Inc. has opened its Advanced Materials Processing (AMP) Showcase Lab near Frankfurt, Germany.
TTM Technologies unveils NY engineering center On the heels of its acquisition of manufacturing and IP assets from i3 Electronics Inc., TTM Technologies has announced the opening of a new engineering center in Binghamton, NY.Load more news