SMT & Inspection | July 01, 2010
Integrated Verification enables IPC-Compliant Inspection
During manufacture of electronic assemblies, production defects are unavoidable. Systems for automatic optical inspection (AOI) have proven themselves in securing product quality.
The guidelines in IPC-A-610D are frequently drawn upon to evaluate and classify potential production defects. When these guidelines are used on an AOI system, several aspects need to be considered in order to assure IPC-compliant inspection. Production defects during the automated assembly and soldering of electronic assemblies are unavoidable. AOI systems are deployed more and more to assure these defects are detected and to further optimize the process. Frequently, these systems are situated after the solder oven for post-reflow inspection, because this inspection stage presents the greatest potential for improving quality. In addition to AOI defect rates (pseudo-defects and slip), recurring themes such as inspection depth, or inspection features and their definition, come to the fore when acceptance criteria are specified. When specifications are described, exact definition of which defects are to be inspected and what exactly a defect is are crucial in preventing later discussion. Overview: IPC-A-610D IPC-A-610D (IPC), as stated above, is a "collection of visual quality acceptability requirements for electronic assemblies." It subdivides assemblies into three classes, each with its own specific criteria (IPC, 1.4.1 Classification): Class 1 – General Electronic Products Class 2 – Dedicated Service Electronic Products Class 3 – High Performance Electronic Products The criteria for each class are then presented in four stages (IPC, 1.4.2 Acceptance Criteria): Target Condition (ideal, to aim for) Acceptable Condition (permissible) Defect Condition (impermissible) Process Indicator Condition The described ideal state cannot always be achieved, making the acceptable condition sufficient. Process indicators comprise a special condition. They are not actual defects, yet do not fully satisfy the acceptance criteria. If an increase in process indicators is observed, the process should be analyzed to further improve production. Illus. 1: IPC-A-610D, 8-20: End joint width/displacement, chip component (Describes the permissible boundaries of end width for Class 3: "The end width of the solder joint (C) is at least 75% of the component connection width (W) or the connection surface width (P), whichever is less.") It should be noted that the IPC-A-610D describes criteria for visual inspection and presents standards for "visual inspection" (IPC, 1.2 Purpose). "Automatic inspection technology (Automatic Optical Inspection (AOI) represents a practical alternative to visual inspection... " (IPC, 1.6 Inspection Methodology). This means, the IPC was explicitly conceived for human visual inspection. Transferability of the criteria to AOI Thus the question arises, to what extent IPC acceptance criteria for electronic assemblies can be directly transferred to AOI. The ideal prospect in many cases is to adopt the dimensions for permissible acceptance conditions displayed in the illustrations as threshold values for AOI. Insofar as an AOI records proportions on the assembly geometrically, comparison with the adopted thresholds delivers the inspection result. However, one aspect deserves consideration here. As explained above, IPC is conceived as a tool for human visual inspection ("AOI as practical alternative"); therefore the threshold values are approximately quantified, as in the 25% increments for evaluation of chip components (Table 8-2). This permits a subjective comparison of the schematic depiction with the actual assembly and the qualitative evaluation of visible features; finer gradations could hardly be implemented. As well, not all dimensions are provided with thresholds, such as in the definition of solder joint length D on cylindrical end cap connections (Melfs). Here the remark: "Visually good wetting" (184.108.40.206) is listed. Certain components, like QFN/MLFs (Table 8-13), receive an even more rudimentary description. Illus. 2: IPC-A-610D, 8-50: Solder joint length on a Melf Illus.3: IPC-A-610D, 8-51, Soldering on a Melf A further example is the handling of "combined conditions." This term refers to the simultaneous occurrence of deviations for at least two features. IPC acceptance criteria are defined individually for each single feature; the large number of possible feature combinations prevent a complete definition. When defect features occur in combination – e.g. insufficient solder on a displaced component – a defect state can be present even though the individual features are within tolerances. This can be detected by a human visual inspection, implying that the human factor is critical in implementing IPC. This discussion points out, simple transfer of available IPC threshold values to AOI is insufficient for inspection of electronic assemblies. The IPC is a tool, yet does not replace the electronic assembly manufacturer's responsibility (nor that of the AOI manufacturer!) for the quality of the finished product. Concept for applying IPC-A-610D to AOI The Viscom concept for using IPC-A-610D together with AOI optimally incorporates IPC, so it is used according to its original intentions. The basic idea is to draw upon IPC for final evaluation of the inspection results at the classification station (review of the inspection results provided by AOI), so a random sampling to verify good and bad examples for the AOI library can result. The following illustration explains this correlation. Illus. 4: Concept for applying IPC to Viscom AOI The AOI delivers inspection results in the form of image data for review at the classification station. Generally there a zero-escape policy is already in place, meaning no defect may be overlooked (1). In actual practice, escape will sometimes occur, such as when defect conditions that were not previously considered crop up. A good AOI must be in the position to provide technology and methodology for such cases, to verifiably preclude repetition of a particular escaped defect. The IPC acceptance criteria are taken into account by IPC-qualified personnel during classification of inspection results and their ultimate evaluation (2). To guarantee the requisite level of knowledge, employees should receive regular training on the basis of pre-classified images, so the quality of evaluations is attained and documented. The software evaluates classified AOI results to automatically sort the defect images. This provides a valuable verification data base containing good and bad templates (3). Based on 25 years of AOI experience, Viscom delivers a corresponding verification data base with its systems, which can then be automatically supplemented by the customer. Feedback into the AOI is provided by reliance on this IPC-compliant verification data base to assess the AOI inspection library (4, 5). Corresponding offline software is employed to automatically verify whether the current parameter settings and thresholds correctly evaluate all template examples in the data base (separation of classes). Illus. 5: Separation of classes during Integrated Verification This verification also produces explicit documents, so IPC-compliant inspection and zero defect escape can be proven during audits as well. Conclusion IPC-A-610D has established and proven itself as a valuable tool in the manual visual inspection of electronic assemblies. A flexible concept for the application of IPC to AOI, like the Integrated Verification from Viscom, is required to fully exploit the performance capabilities of modern AOIs. The assumption that available IPC thresholds need only be uploaded to the AOI and numerically compared with the geometric actual state is inadequate to support a zero-escape approach. Integrated Verification provides an image-based, classified verification data base for the manual review of inspection results, which can consider all influences and criteria for the good/bad decision and deliver optimal flexibility: in addition to IPC, individual manufacturer requirements can also be incorporated. Good software tools working automatically and offline are decisive in benefiting from this exceptionally valuable data base in connection with an IPC-compliant inspection. Without additional time expenditure, conformance of the AOI inspection library (and ultimately, the AOI itself) to IPC stipulations is attained to secure a zero-escape inspection. Of course, since the IPC also describes many criteria that are not optically visible, this concept can also be fully applied to X-ray assembly inspection. ----- Author: Peter Krippner, Vice President Assembly Inspection, Viscom AG
A new EMS provider sees the light of day EMS providers DataED and Bestronics merge to launch a new player – Emerald EMS.
Tektronix joins the fight agains COVID-19 Tektronix has shifted its focus from supporting vehicle manufacturing to assisting with ventilator production.
ABB completes divestment of Power Grids to Hitachi ABB has reached a significant milestone in the company’s transformation towards a decentralized global technology company, with the completion of the divestment of 80.1% of its Power Grids business to Hitachi.
Germany amps up domestic battery production with massive state subsidies The German government is investing more than EUR 1.5 billion in battery cell research and production.
Internal promotions and executive retirements at Kimball EMS provider, Kimball Electronics, has made two new internal promotions aimed at contributing to the company accelerating its strategic growth plans.
Kyocera & TMDU team up for research on vitals measurement headset Kyocera Corporation and Tokyo Medical and Dental University (TMDU) have teamed up on a joint research project to develop a wireless headset that can remotely monitor high accuracy patient biometrics, such as blood oxygen saturation (SpO2).
German battery manufacturer receives funding for cell production facility VARTA AG receives public funding of EUR 300 million for battery cell production facility.
Scanfil to streamline its factory network The EMS provider is planning to combine the production of its Hamburg factory with its other factories in Germany and Poland
Kitron awarded new order within measurement technology Kitron has been awarded new business for measurement technology. The award covers a period of five years, and the expected annual value is between EUR 3.5-5 million.
NORBIT ASA awarded aquaculture contract Norwegian technology manufacturer, NORBIT, has been awarded a new contract from an existing customer within the aquaculture market.
Saki strengthens its Asian operations The AOI specialist is expanding its global sales organisation with new Asia sales department, and appointing Katsuhiro Eddie Ichiyama as Senior General Manager for the Asian region
Scanfil to sell its plant in Hangzhou, China The board of directors of the Finnish EMS prover has decided to sell the entire share capital of its subsidiary located in Hangzhou, China, for a total of EUR 18.4 million to Hangzhou Cabinet Technology Co., Ltd.
Staying put during the COVID-19 pandemic TPCA (Taiwan Printed Circuit Association) announced the production and sales data for Q1 2020; the output value of Taiwan cross-strait PCB industry totalled NT$136.9 billion (approx. US$4.541 billion) in Q1/2020.
North American PCB industry sales up 1.0% in May Total North American PCB shipments in May 2020 were up 1.0 percent compared to the same month last year. Compared to the preceding month, May shipments fell 3.0 percent.
Sensirion expands with new production site in Hungary In a response to positive business trends and the increasing demand for its existing and new sensors, Sensirion is expanding its production capabilities by establishing a production site in Debrecen, Hungary.
Management Change at the Würth Elektronik eiSos Group After 27 years in the Würth Elektronik Group, Oliver Konz has decided to resign his position as Executive Vice President of the Würth Group and CEO of the Würth Elektronik eiSos Group for personal reasons and leave the company.
Kurtz Ersa inaugurates new production hall In Bestenheid, Germany, the company has just opened its new production and administration building. Following 24 months of construction and furnishing, the company now have access to 4’500 new square metres of space.
PCB industry: 1Q/2020 overshadowed by corona pandemic After a significant drop in sales at the end of last year, PCB manufacturers in the Germany, Austria and Switzerland (DACH) region recorded a sales growth of 16.1 percent in the first quarter of 2020.
Integration of ATLID completes European set of instruments for EarthCARE satellite With the successful integration of the ATLID-Instrument the EarthCARE satellite (Clouds Aerosols and Radiation Explorer) has passed a crucial milestone, as it concludes the "onboarding" of the three European instruments.
ABB Robotics rolls out Lexi’s procurement analytics solution Automation giant, ABB Robotics, is using a big data analytics software solution developed by Lexi Solution AB in Sweden to optimise procurement and engineering processes.
OHB placing the largest clean room in operation After only 14 months of construction, the PLATO hall has now been officially completed at space company OHB’s headquarters in Bremen. With a floor area of around 1,400 square meters, the ISO 8 cleanroom*, which is almost eleven meters high, is the OHB Group’s largest cleanroom facility.
Jenoptik expands military laser rangefinder capabilities in the US JENOPTIK Optical Systems, LLC has announced an expansion of its capabilities for military laser rangefinders (LRF) and is adding custom engineering and testing capabilities to their Jupiter, Florida facility.
Tesla plans battery manufacturing facility in California Electric car manufacturer Tesla plans to build a battery research and manufacturing facility in Fremont, California. N, to be operated around the clock, Under a project dubbed Roadrunner, documents from the city government also reveal a potential 24/7 operation at the facility.
Northrop Grumman awards contracts to Kitron Northrop Grumman has awarded Kitron a production contract for Integrated Communications, Navigation and Identification (ICNI) modules for the F-35 Lightning II program.Load more news