Electronics Production | June 07, 2010
The True Cost of Outsourcing
Foxconn and Apple have been in the national business press recently over human rights issues related to worker suicides. CBA has commented on several occasions on the topic, including recently in a response to our 5Q/5A column.
The stories have focused on the secrecy of Foxconn, the low wage rates, and the overall unhappiness of workers, who are primarily young, single Chinese men and women from rural areas who are isolated from friends and family in complexes and are forced to sign exploitative labor contracts. In one video, a Financial Times journalist was allowed to enter the compound in Shenzhen and film never-before seen shots of palm tree-lined boulevards, restaurants and shops filled with smiling, neatly dressed Chinese youth that are now flooding the blogosphere. A young woman is interviewed while she peacefully works on needlepoint. She says through a Foxconn translator that she's very happy working at Foxconn and looking forward to earning enough money to go back home and get married soon. Since it doesn't look that bad to most people – kind of like a college campus in San Diego – the human rights furor is subsiding. Foxconn announced they will raise labor rates by 30% (!!) and so we're betting the public relations crisis is over, iPads are selling at record-breaking pace, and all is right in Cupertino. We predict the net impact of the story will be, once again, to focus on the effect of all this on labor rates. OEMs will start worrying that China is no longer cheap enough for their electronics manufacturing projects and start looking at Vietnam, Tunisia, or some other exotic location where workers can be exploited with impunity. This thinking is wrong, wrong, wrong, on several fronts. Front one: Human Rights Let's be realistic about what happened with the spin doctors. Chinese managers are masterful at manipulating Western reporters, so it is inconceivable that the FT video is typical of worker conditions at Foxconn. And the issue isn't what certain parts of the facility look like. It's the experience of the typical worker, who stands jammed up against hundreds of other workers doing one narrowly defined task for 12 hour shifts with no break, day after day and then goes to a dormitory with 100’s of other workers to sleep. Neither the wages nor the working hours allow for any social life; a 30% increase on next to nothing is still just slightly more than nothing. The extra dollar a day won’t solve the underlying problem. Humans are not robots; they need community, relaxation, freedom. The Foxconn facilities – unlike similar enterprises in most other parts of the global – regulate workers 24/7. That's how most people define prison. Front two: labor rates In electronics manufacturing, wages paid to direct labor employees account for only a tiny fraction of what an OEM pays for outsourcing services (i.e. materials account for the vast majority of their spend). Our case-studies prove that once the other elements of cost are introduced into the equation, OEMs almost never save a substantial amount of money in a cross-hemispheric solution no matter how low the labor rate is. This has always been true for lower volume, higher mix electronics but is now becoming more commonly true with higher volume electronics. Costs in China (and what OEMs spend internally in support of their outsourcing initiatives) have been rising dramatically, and it has nothing to do with the cost of labor in Foxconn’s factories. Front three: the elephant in the room Concurrent to the Foxconn human rights stories were the announcements of the Chinese knock-off 'iPed' and the Chinese version of the iPhone that have both gone on sale in the vast Chinese consumer market. This serves to remind OEMs of the near total lack of intellectual property protection afforded to companies doing business in China, promises to the WTO notwithstanding. For those C-level executives expecting to capture domestic demand through use of the Chinese national supply base: think again. If Apple can't protect its IP in China, no one can. There are still situations where a Chinese-based manufacturing solution makes sense, but the days of the wholesale transfer of the electronics manufacturing industry are over. We have the reality-based data to show you exactly how to configure your global electronics manufacturing program to optimize competitive advantage, innovation and cost effectiveness. But it can’t be done via a one-dimensional analysis based on cheap labor rates. ----- Author: Charlie Barnhart
Keysight, FormFactor and CompoundTek to collaborate Keysight, FormFactor and CompoundTek, have formed a joint plan to provide an advanced photonics on-wafer testing solution to include automated alignment, simultaneous optical-optical and optical-electrical device tests.
Wireless Telecom buys Holzworth Instrumentation Wireless Telecom Group Inc. has signed a definitive agreement to acquire Holzworth Instrumentation Inc., a Boulder, Colorado-based provider of specialty phase noise analyzers and signal generators.
NCAB Group acquires Altus-PCB in USA Altus-PCB is a full-service supplier of PCBs based in New Jersey, USA, that has a business model similar to NCAB’s. Tee US company has a high level of technical expertise and sells mainly to original equipment manufacturers (OEMs).
Mycronic's Thomas Stetter looks back at a successful year As the company is moving more and more towards becoming a full solutions provider, business is taking off and the numbers show very much confirms that the Mycronic's strategy is working.
Sponsored content by NCAB Group Benelux B.V.Failure is not an option for a PCB More than 30% of the Gerbers NCAB Group Benelux B.V. reviews, have problems. However, the PCB are integrated in key end-user product with more and more High Tech PCB. We are here to support you on the new technologies growth to maintain a high reliability and quality. Contact us to review it together.
IBL Löttechnik reviews 2019 IBL Löttechnik GmbH is staying on top of the market thanks to continues R&D investments.
Second install for EFI at Mid America Display Silicon Valley’s EFI will install a second EFI Nozomi C18000 single-pass inkjet, direct-to-board printer later this month to Mid America Display.
Ron Jakeman of Electrolube looks back at a successful 2019 Electrolube has been growing, both in terms of its footprint and financially, for a number of years not; Ron Jakeman details the company's progress.
Etteplan and Scanfil to start strategic cooperation in joint customer projects Engineering company Etteplan and contract manufacturer Scanfil have today agreed to enter a strategic partnership in Finland.
The lovechild of ACE Production and InterSelect Carlos Bouras of Nordson Select gave us the rundown of the result of the integration and combination of ACE Production and InterSelect GmbH - the new Integra.
American Battery Metals, U.S. lawmakers convene American Battery Metals Corporation has completed a series of meetings with lawmakers and personnel in the Department of Energy and Department of the Interior in Washington, D.C., to discuss issues critical to the domestic battery production and storage industry.
Cogiscan, Critical Mfg. form strategic partnership Quebec, Canada-based Cogiscan and Critical Manufacturing, headquartered in Portugal, have forged a strategic partnership to deliver smart factory solutions for electronics manufacturers.
Collins Aerospace expanding in North Africa Collins Aerospace Systems, a unit of United Technologies Corp., has taken the first step toward the expansion of its existing site in Casablanca, Morocco.
Sponsored content by EsemdaContract manufacturer Esemda opens new facility in Vilnius and expands EMS The new facility has been built with reserved space for future expansions. As Esemda constantly grows, it is of great importance to be able to rapidly increase production capacity in large volumes.
The advantage of Vantage - Garrett Wong tells the tale Nordson Asymtek's Garrett Wong gives us a rundown of the business year and also details the Vantage Advantage
Saki’s Eddie Ichiyama details a very successful business year Eddie ichiyama from Saki gave us an update on how 2019 has been for the company and also shared some details on the recent expansion in the Czech Republic.
The ripple effect of Enrico Krog Iversen while being an active part in creating one of the fastest growing robotics companies in modern time might have been enough for most people, that does not seem to have slowed down a certain Danish entrepreneur.
Yamaha's Ichiro Arimoto on the business year and the company's new ventures Evertiq had the opportunity to talk to Ichiro Arimoto, General Manager of Yamaha Motor Europe, about the business year and the company's new ventures.
Sponsored content by Nordson ASYMTEKStart-to-finish conformal coating with reliability and efficiency Nordson ASYMTEK’s flexible, modular, Panorama™ S-Line delivers conformal coating process control in a space-saving footprint with overlapping line processes that minimize manufacturing floor space. This innovative, patent-pending line layout trims 50% of the line’s length by using the lower compartment in each piece of equipment for functional use. Combined with Nordson ASYMTEK’s global support, this complete conformal coating line delivers quality, product reliability, efficiency, and safety for all your conformal coating applications.
Mycronic, Indium forge strategic partnership Indium Corporation has announced a strategic partnership with Sweden-based Mycronic, to develop no-clean and water soluble solder pastes for jetting applications.
SCHMID delivers PlasmaLine to Hofstetter PCB SCHMID announced it has installed the company’s first PlasmaLine comprising ICP etch & sputter deposition of its Korean JV SCHMID AVACO at Hofstetter PCB AG in Switzerland.
Cobot market to reach USD 9+ billion by 2025 A new report from Tractica is forecasting continued rapid growth for the global collaborative robot (cobot) market over the next few years, reaching revenue of USD 9.7 billion by 2025.
MixComm scores USD 8+ million in series B round New Jersey-based fabless semiconductor company MixComm has secured USD 8.6 million in series B funding led by existing investor, Kairos Ventures.
Sponsored content by SourcengineComponent Aggregators vs E-Commerce Marketplaces What is the difference between electronic component aggregators and a marketplace?
67% of a buyer’s journey is now done digitally. Learn how marketplaces emerged as full-cycle procurement platforms and challenged the traditional component aggregators.
SIA elects 2020 leadership The Semiconductor Industry Association (SIA) Board of Directors has elected ON Semiconductor CEO Keith Jackson as its 2020 Chair and Qorvo CEO Robert Bruggeworth as its 2020 Vice Chair.
Si wafer shipments recede for fourth straight quarter Worldwide silicon wafer area shipments slid for the fourth consecutive quarter of 2019, according to the SEMI Silicon Manufacturers Group (SMG) in its most recent quarterly analysis of the industry.
Decline in Q4 DRAM contract prices lessens as buying momentum recovers According to the latest analysis from the DRAMeXchange research division of TrendForce, Q4 DRAM ASP is as of yet undergoing a slight QoQ decline, but this decline has shrunk down to 5%.
Technica forms growth-focused equity fund San Jose-based Technica USA has reached an agreement on an equity investment centered on future growth for the global PCB fab and assembly supplier.Load more news