Electronics Production | June 07, 2010
The True Cost of Outsourcing
Foxconn and Apple have been in the national business press recently over human rights issues related to worker suicides. CBA has commented on several occasions on the topic, including recently in a response to our 5Q/5A column.
The stories have focused on the secrecy of Foxconn, the low wage rates, and the overall unhappiness of workers, who are primarily young, single Chinese men and women from rural areas who are isolated from friends and family in complexes and are forced to sign exploitative labor contracts. In one video, a Financial Times journalist was allowed to enter the compound in Shenzhen and film never-before seen shots of palm tree-lined boulevards, restaurants and shops filled with smiling, neatly dressed Chinese youth that are now flooding the blogosphere. A young woman is interviewed while she peacefully works on needlepoint. She says through a Foxconn translator that she's very happy working at Foxconn and looking forward to earning enough money to go back home and get married soon. Since it doesn't look that bad to most people – kind of like a college campus in San Diego – the human rights furor is subsiding. Foxconn announced they will raise labor rates by 30% (!!) and so we're betting the public relations crisis is over, iPads are selling at record-breaking pace, and all is right in Cupertino. We predict the net impact of the story will be, once again, to focus on the effect of all this on labor rates. OEMs will start worrying that China is no longer cheap enough for their electronics manufacturing projects and start looking at Vietnam, Tunisia, or some other exotic location where workers can be exploited with impunity. This thinking is wrong, wrong, wrong, on several fronts. Front one: Human Rights Let's be realistic about what happened with the spin doctors. Chinese managers are masterful at manipulating Western reporters, so it is inconceivable that the FT video is typical of worker conditions at Foxconn. And the issue isn't what certain parts of the facility look like. It's the experience of the typical worker, who stands jammed up against hundreds of other workers doing one narrowly defined task for 12 hour shifts with no break, day after day and then goes to a dormitory with 100’s of other workers to sleep. Neither the wages nor the working hours allow for any social life; a 30% increase on next to nothing is still just slightly more than nothing. The extra dollar a day won’t solve the underlying problem. Humans are not robots; they need community, relaxation, freedom. The Foxconn facilities – unlike similar enterprises in most other parts of the global – regulate workers 24/7. That's how most people define prison. Front two: labor rates In electronics manufacturing, wages paid to direct labor employees account for only a tiny fraction of what an OEM pays for outsourcing services (i.e. materials account for the vast majority of their spend). Our case-studies prove that once the other elements of cost are introduced into the equation, OEMs almost never save a substantial amount of money in a cross-hemispheric solution no matter how low the labor rate is. This has always been true for lower volume, higher mix electronics but is now becoming more commonly true with higher volume electronics. Costs in China (and what OEMs spend internally in support of their outsourcing initiatives) have been rising dramatically, and it has nothing to do with the cost of labor in Foxconn’s factories. Front three: the elephant in the room Concurrent to the Foxconn human rights stories were the announcements of the Chinese knock-off 'iPed' and the Chinese version of the iPhone that have both gone on sale in the vast Chinese consumer market. This serves to remind OEMs of the near total lack of intellectual property protection afforded to companies doing business in China, promises to the WTO notwithstanding. For those C-level executives expecting to capture domestic demand through use of the Chinese national supply base: think again. If Apple can't protect its IP in China, no one can. There are still situations where a Chinese-based manufacturing solution makes sense, but the days of the wholesale transfer of the electronics manufacturing industry are over. We have the reality-based data to show you exactly how to configure your global electronics manufacturing program to optimize competitive advantage, innovation and cost effectiveness. But it can’t be done via a one-dimensional analysis based on cheap labor rates. ----- Author: Charlie Barnhart
Teslas German venture comes to a halt following court order A court in Germany has ordered the US electric carmaker to stop clearing the forest at its future location outside Berlin.
Marposs expands with acquisition of Stil Precision metrology equipment supplier Marposs has acquired STIL S.A.S., a French company specializing in research, development, production and sales of optical measurement instruments.
Z-AXIS shares good news from 2019 Electronics design and CMS provider Z-AXIS Inc. released 2019 data showing showing robust revenue growth as well as an expansion to its workforce.
Fluidra reaches a deal to acquire Fabtronics Fluidra, a company within the pool and wellness equipment industry, has acquired Australian electronics manufacturer Fabtronics to strengthen its R&D capabilities and to incorporate complete, efficient and cost-effective electronics design and manufacturing solutions.
Garz & Fricke acquires Keith & Koep Hamburg-based Garz & Fricke Group has acquired Keith & Koep GmbH, located in Wuppertal, Germany. With this move, a new powerhouse for ARM-based embedded technologies in Europe has been formed.
ABB to close Hungarian plant – 1’000 jobs lost The power and automation company will close its production facility in Ozd, in northeastern Hungary, by the end of the year.
AT&S' plant Chongqing II back in operation Austrian PCB manufacturer, AT&S, announces that the Plant II at its Chinese location in Chongqing will resume operations.
Arçelik A.Ş files IP lawsuit against LG Arçelik A.S, owners of the Beko and Grundig brands, filed a lawsuit against LG Electronics and its subsidiaries in Germany and France for patent infringement in relation to the unlicensed implementation of the company’s direct drive technology in LG Electronics’ “6 Motion” washing machines.
Seagate unifying workforce at green Fremont site Data storage and management solutions provider Seagate Technology plc is consolidating its San Francisco Bay Area workforce by relocating the company’s Cupertino operations to its existing sustainable Fremont facility.
Coronavirus afflicts more electronic supply chains With the epidemic arriving at dawn of 5G’s mainstream deployment phase, the coronavirus has the potential to disrupt the progress of the next-generation wireless standard, as the crisis slows or threatens to slow the production of key smartphone components, including displays and semiconductors, according to Omdia.
Solid financial improvements for Kitron EMS provider Kitron could show off solid financial improvements, both for the fourth quarter and full year 2019.
Zollner resumes operations in China The German EMS provider Zollner says that its plant in Taicang is reopened. Work continues under strict safety conditions and not to the full extent.
Step-by-Step: Foxconn makes progress in WI Next construction phases of vertical construction, including steel placement, have commenced at Foxconn’s 296,000-square-foot Smart Manufacturing Center at the Wisconn Valley Science and Technology Park (WVSTP).
Eaton boosts offerings with acquisition of PDI Inc. Power management company Eaton has struck a deal to purchase Virginia-based Power Distribution Inc. (PDI), a supplier of mission critical power distribution, static switching, and power monitoring equipment.
BASF to set up cathode active material production in Germany BASF is planning a new battery materials production site in Schwarzheide, Germany, as part of its multi-step investment plan to support the European electric vehicle (EV) value chain.
Shipment from China to GPV sites worldwide has restarted Some of GPV's most important suppliers in China are back in operation which means that important shipment to GPV sites worldwide has restarted. However, not all supplies might be complete, the company says.
Orbit One expands with new test team in Poland The Swedish EMS provider is launching another test team within the group.
Volvo and Geely considers a combined company Volvo Car AB and Geely Automobile Holdings Limited are considering combining their businesses to create a strong global group, which would accelerate financial and technological synergies between the two companies.
Cepton nails major funding from Koito Lidar technology specialist Cepton Technologies Inc. has secured USD 50 million in Series C funding from Koito Manufacturing Co. Ltd., a Tier 1 provider of automotive lighting systems.
RoboSense obtains IATF 16949 certification Automotive LiDAR manufacturer, RoboSense, has obtained the IATF 16949 certificate in the automotive field, which now fully qualifies it to supply to automotive customers.
Manz to deliver assembly lines to Akasol for battery production Manz AG has received an order from the German Akasol AG for assembly lines to produce lithium-ion battery modules. The placing of the order with a total volume of up to EUR 20 million euros has been split into several tranches.
ZKW with new locations in Korea and China The ZKW Group ended 2019 by establishing a branch in Incheon, Korea, near Seoul.
Connected Community Networks picks up Introbotix Colorado-based Connected Community Networks (CCN), a provider of products and services for development, verification and manufacturing in the high-frequency electronics space, has acquired testing specialist Introbotix.
GPV's Chinese facility will remain closed The Chinese Central Government and the Chinese Epidemic Command Centre have prolonged the curfew in the provinces Hubei and Guangdong. Guangdong (Pearl River delta) is the second most affected province in China and also the province where GPV’s production site is situated.Load more news