Electronics Production | November 09, 2009
Just in Case (Study)
By Charlie Barnhart: Earlier this year we worked with an OEM client on a case-study involving serial supply failures in China. The OEM is a well known, publicly traded, industrial equipment provider with over twenty years of outsourcing experience.
The EMS companies are both reputable industry sources; one headquartered in Asia the other in North America. The project was a forecast based, batch build of a relatively simple controller-type box (less than a dozen configurations) in single container-sized weekly quantities. In this case, supply failure was defined by the OEM deciding to pull the business from one EMS Company and move it to another; which has now occurred twice. In other words, the OEM is now working with their third EMS supplier on this project (in less than two years). Hopefully, I’ve got your attention. Before we continue, please respond to the following: What was the root cause of the failure in the above example? 1. Intrinsic problems with manufacturing in China 2. Issues related to the OEM’s approach 3. Issues related to the EMS value proposition and/or execution 4. All of the above 5. None of the above 6. If you don’t get to the point PDQ I’m going to stop reading this article! The correct answer is 6, which is the one you probably chose as more than a few of us working in Outsourcing (either OEM or EMS) suffer from a chronic and debilitating psychological syndrome we call “Recognizing Realities Deficit Disorder” or R2D2. This is actually a weaponized version of the more familiar Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD). No worries, it’s not your fault. We don’t blame you. You didn’t catch this disease because you were a bad girl/boy and refused to eat your spinach. You contracted it by working in a crazy industry that has made you (well…) a little crazy. And for senior management, this disorder is even more serious as it can actually cause blindness. The folks who are really to blame are (in no particular order): 1. Every business school who stopped talking about Joe (if you don’t know what that means then it doesn’t apply to you). 2. Everyone who stopped thinking about manufacturing the day the term "core-competency" was coined. 3. Every C-Level Executive who thinks more about EPS than product innovation (not to be confused with market or business innovation, as those are the dung heaps where the R2D2 germs thrive!) 4. Anyone who works on Wall Street or any other Street where people discuss credit-default swaps or any other imaginary financial instrument. 5. And of course George W. who is by default the recipient of all not otherwise assigned blame. With that said, let’s (finally!) take a look at what happened, why it happened, and what we can learn so it doesn’t happen to any of us in the future. THE GOOD There’s nothing intrinsically wrong (then or now) with manufacturing in China; obviously, FIT (Flexibility, Integration and Timing) is critical when working with any outsourcing solution and especially so when working with geographically remote solutions. Nevertheless, many of the best equipped, operated and technologically capable electronic manufacturing facilities in the world are now located in China. In our case-study China FIT was not the problem, and even though the demand and supply solution were not 100% congruent from a needs/value-proposition perspective they were reasonably within the boundaries of many successful comparables. Nor were there any substantive technical or organizational deficiencies at either of the EMS companies; the OEM’s requirements and the EMS companies’ capabilities were reasonably aligned. Further, the OEM, while probably not 100% appreciative of the complexity of doing business in China (more on this later), accurately articulated the requirements of their program to the EMS companies and the EMS companies clearly understood and agreed to these requirements. In fact, the EMS applied (I suspect much to their chagrin) considerably more technical and operational resource to the program (before they were eliminated) than they had originally committed in their quotations. THE BAD The OEM, who had received training on the risk-module of the Outsourcing Navigator Series, apparently forgot… or perhaps more accurately their executive management elected to forget… that to implement a cost effective and risk appropriate Outsourcing solution there needs to be an alignment between the Expectations & Internal Resources of the OEM and the Capabilities of the Supply Solution. Success (or failure) isn’t just about the Expectations of the OEM and Capabilities of the EMS; the OEM also needs to bring sufficient Internal Resources to the union to support their Expectations! If you’re an OEM, you know that your True Cost of Outsourcing isn’t just what you pay your EMS suppliers but also includes your internal investment for staffing, travel, experience leveling (where gaps exist… like, doing business in China), IS/IT and Design Engineering support, technology sharing & training (again for where gaps exist… like, proprietary software and testing), forecasting management, etcetera. Make no mistake, when these expenditures are withheld and/or simply eliminated, the probability of failure increases. This is not speculation, it is demonstrable by this and dozens of similar case-studies. THE UGLY Yes, you guessed it, after much chagrin and teeth gnashing the root-cause failure was determined to be a COST CUTTING program. But not some run of the mill cost cutting program – a new punitive R2D2 form of cost cutting where everyone is “punished” by cutting costs whenever there is a problem – intentional or not, that’s what actually happened. All of which reminds me of a tee-shirt that says, “The beatings will continue until morale improves.” While this was going on those who worked at the OEM (especially on the outsourcing team) were not able to overcome this most severe outcome imposed by the R2D2 thinking, and so maintained a very low profile and ultimately millions of dollars were squandered to save a few thousands. Fortunately today, some progress has been made, the product has been moved back on-shore (to Mexico) which has reduced the level of spend required to support a geographically remote solution and there has been some (if limited) acknowledgement by management that the CEO’s dictate to go to China and their simultaneous budget cuts were “a bit asynchronous” (wouldn’t it be cool if buzz-words caused the speaker’s head to explode?) What’s the bottom-line? Even smart people can make bad decisions – especially when they’re in the R2D2 zone. We need to slow down and get control. We’ve all been doing this for a long time and know that short-cuts and half-measures end up costing, not saving money. You want to go manufacture in China – great – remember Copy Exact? It worked 20 years ago and it will still work today. “Seamless integration” of a manufacturing solution is all about substance not some passing R2D2 fad! ----- Author: Charlie Barnhart, Barnhart & Associates
Signify to acquire Cooper Lighting Signify has entered into a definitive agreement with Eaton to acquire Cooper Lighting Solutions for USD 1.4 billion in cash.
Winbond, Karamba Security forge partnership Karamba Security, a provider of embedded cybersecurity for connected machines, announced it is collaborating with Winbond Electronics, a supplier of semiconductor memory solutions.
U.S. silicon industry presses Congress for inclusion in tariff talks Three major U.S. silicon industry manufacturers urged members of congress to include tariffs, imposed by the Chinese on U.S. exports of polysilicon to China since 2014, in ongoing U.S. trade talks with the country.
ESD-Center aims to conquer the Baltics After 15 years of working the Baltic market, ESD-center, a Swedish supplier to the electronics industry, established its first office in Pärnu, Estonia in April of 2019.
EV manufacturer adds Chinese subsidiary for in-country operations ElectraMeccanica Vehicles, a designer and manufacturer of electric vehicles, has established EMV Automotive Technology, Inc. (Chongqing), a wholly-owned subsidiary, in China.
Silicon Labs acquires Qulsar's IEEE 1588 software and modules Silicon Labs has acquired all IEEE 1588 precision time protocol (PTP) software and module assets from Qulsar, a provider of PTP grandmasters, gateways and other system-level synchronization-based solutions.
GPV expands warehouse in Thailand GPV’s electronics production facility in Thailand has officially opened its new, 2,300 square metres warehouse.
US DoD to invest in SkyWater’s domestic technology foundry The U.S. DoD is planning to invest up to USD 170 million in SkyWater Technology for a project that will enhance its microelectronics capabilities and the strategic radiation hardened (rad-hard) market.
Sponsored content by Sourceability NA LLCComponent Aggregators vs E-Commerce Marketplaces What is the difference between electronic component aggregators and a marketplace?
67% of a buyer’s journey is now done digitally. Learn how marketplaces emerged as full-cycle procurement platforms and challenged the traditional component aggregators.
FANUC America opening robotics and automation facility Robotics solutions provider FANUC America held a grand opening celebration at its new 461,000 square-foot North Campus robotics and automation facility in Auburn Hills, Michigan this week.
Up on the roof: Foxconn hits milestone in WI Foxconn's Wisconn Valley Science & Technology Park is closing in on having “roof” checked off the list of tasks with the recent start of the roof installation on the nearly 1,000,000 square-foot TFT LCD fab.
Plasmatreat opens new technology and research centre Plasmatreat says that it is opening its new technology and research centre, Plasma Campus, at the its headquarter in Steinhagen. In the 1'400 square meter facility, new areas of application for plasma technology will be developed.
NOTE reports growth across the board The Swedish EMS provider is reporting record growth, a stronger operating margin and about 30% larger order backlog during its third quarter.
PCB Connect expands to Turkey Swedish PCB supplier PCB Connect is continuing its growth and has, since the first of September, established a local presence in Turkey.
Teradyne strikes deal for AutoGuide Mobile Robots Massachusetts-based Teradyne has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire privately held AutoGuide for USD 165 million.
Major investments part of tentative UAW, GM deal Details of the tentative agreement hatched between General Motors and UAW last week are emerging, including GM’s pledge to invest USD 3 billion in the Detroit-Hamtramck assembly plant.
CATL starts construction of its first overseas factory in Germany A groundbreaking ceremony of the first overseas factory for lithium-ion battery maker CATL took place on October 18 in Thuringia, Germany, marking the start of construction of the first lithium-ion battery factory in Germany.
Mycronic delivers mask writer to Asia Swedish Mycronic says it has received an order for a Prexision-series mask writer for display applications from an existing customer in Asia.
Protolabs invest GBP 5M in expansion Protolabs, digital manufacturer of custom prototypes and low-volume production parts, has announced a GBP 5 5million expansion plan at its European Headquarters in Telford (UK).
Joyson Safety invests in Hungary Joyson Safety Systems is starting a new investment round at its Hungarian facility in Miskolc. The EUR 50 million investment project aims to improve efficiency and increase production volume.
REC Group starts mass production on Meyer Burger equipment Norway-headquartered solar module manufacturer REC Group has started mass production of its new Alpha modules. This new generation of modules is manufactured on Meyer Burger HJT/SmartWire core equipment.
AQ Group opens new Wiring Systems factory in Poland AQ Group has officially opened a new production facility for their AQ Wiring Systems unit in Łódź (Poland).
Mynaric secures €1.7 million contract Mynaric will deliver multiple laser communication flight terminals to an undisclosed customer in an initial deal valued at EUR 1.7 million.
EMPA spin-off TwingTec takes flight Anyone who has ever steered a child's kite knows the feeling: the wind grips the kite and pulls the string. The rope is quickly tensioned, the pulley rotates between the fingers and is difficult to control. The question arises: Could this wild energy not only be used to play, but also to generate electricity?Load more news