Electronics Production | May 30, 2008
Former US ambassador warns of threat to REACH
The former US Ambassador to the European Union, Stuart Eizenstat, has warned of the “chilling signal” for EU-US trade if political activists are allowed to undermine European chemical legislation, after a green think-tank proposed that a range of fire safety products should be banned under EU law despite having passed exhaustive European risk assessments.
Writing in /European Voice/, The Economist Group’s influential weekly newspaper about EU Affairs, Eizenstat warns that the long-awaited REACH Directive could be compromised before it has even been given a chance to succeed by a separate decision now pending under the so-called RoHS Directive.
“The shared EU-US goal of barrier-free transatlantic trade risks being undermined by regulatory decisions that increasingly seem divorced from sound scientific assessments,” he writes.
Eizenstat argues that a central component of governmental efforts to enhance transatlantic trade has been the implementation of REACH, which would provide consistent and predictable regulatory treatment of thousands of chemicals used in products throughout the European Union.
This is also essential to industry across the Atlantic, allowing US companies to avoid needlessly producing two different products and conduct two sets of duplicative tests because they face two sets of standards.
Eizenstat cites the example of brominated flame retardants, chemicals found in furniture, fabrics, and electronics, which, he says are vital for keeping us safe from fire. “Without flame retardants, many more Europeans would be injured or perish each year in fires, along with substantial additional property losses and environmental damage.”
He continues: “Brominated flame retardants are a perfect example of the risk-benefit balance, based on scientific assessments, that REACH and the RoHS Directive were designed to resolve. Flame retardants are in furniture, fabrics, and electronics, and they are vital to preventing human injury and property destruction from fires. In airplanes, for example, flame retardants increase the safety margin in the case of a catastrophe by increasing the available evacuation time. Indeed, flame retardants are essential to meeting many countries’ fire safety and consumer products safety regulations and standards”.
“Through scientific assessments, regulators can balance risks from the use of flame retardants, if any, and the added public safety benefit from fire suppression. Because the decision-making process can often become technical – examining the risks inherent in specific chemical applications, the substitutes available, and the efficacy of the substitutes – these decisions are best left to scientists rather than interest group pressure.”
Eizenstat, who acts as an advisor to the brominated flame retardant industry, is scathing of a recent study, carried out by the Oko Institut for the European Commission, which lists about 46 chemical compounds – including several flame retardants that have been targeted by activists – to be considered for a ban under the old RoHS Directive - despite the new REACH Directive coming into force.
Extraordinarily, he says, many of these chemicals have already satisfactorily passed exhaustive EU risk assessments, conducted by the EU’s scientific experts, which specifically concluded that the products are safe to human health and the environment.
The consultants’ report, he says, sends a chilling signal to the marketplace. “While it is an initial draft and the Öko Institut may well narrow the list, the message has nonetheless been delivered that scientific assessments are at risk of being ignored. If this proposal is allowed to stand, these chemicals could be banned, contrary to scientific assessments and even before REACH has had an opportunity to evaluate the relative risks and benefits.”
He concludes by saying that this throws into doubt the EU’s commitment to sound regulatory processes, based on scientific assessments, transparency, and procedural rights – and that it would take the transatlantic relationship back to arbitrary decision-making, opaque process, and inconsistent regulations.
Article written by Bsef.
Image Source: RSC (The Royal Society of Chemistry)
Shell to acquire german battery manufacturer sonnen
Shell Overseas Investment B.V. has agreed to acquire 100% of sonnen, a manufacturer of...
Engaged & happy employees - clear drivers of growth & health for Season Group
EMS provider Season Group, is flagging a major change in its organisation, both operational and somewhat philosophical. Randy Ziegenhagel, previously VP Business Development, is moving to the new position of Global Culture Officer and...
BB Electronics expands into Eastern Europe via acquisition
Danish EMS provider BB Electronics has acquired Czech company Wendell Electronics.
UK manufacturer doubles work space in head office acquisition
Yorkshire-based Contract Production Ltd has acquired its current head office and production facilities in Pickering, expanding into a third adjoining unit as part of its expansion programme.
Aquantia and Sumitomo Electric to deliver multi-gig Ethernet connectivity to...
Sumitomo Electric Industries Ltd., based in Japan, and Silicon Valley’s Aquantia Corp. have...
Lockheed Martin opens Florida R&D center, adds jobs
Lockheed Martin has completed construction on its USD 50 million, 255,000 square foot...
UAT picks Veeco to bolster fan-out wafer-level packaging portfolio
Unisem Advanced Technologies Sdn Bhd (UAT) has purchased Veeco’s single-wafer solvent...
ESI gets Asia order for FPC laser via drilling system
Electro Scientific Industries (ESI), a division of MKS Instruments Inc. and provider of laser-based...
DMASS: 'the highest distribution sales ever reported in Europe'
DMASS reports 14.2% growth in semiconductor distribution for Q4/CY18. Smaller countries and Eastern Europe benefit over-proportionally. MOS Micro and Optoelectronics below average, says DMASS.
Merger between Widex and Sivantos receives final clearance
The European Commission has approved the merger between Sivantos (owned by EQT funds)...
Finmasi Group acquires German PCB manufacturer
On the 21st of January 2019 Finmasi Group bought 100% of the capital stock of EPN Electroprint GmbH, located in Neustadt in Thuringia region in Germany.
NCAB expands to Malaysia
NCAB Group starts the first quarter of 2019 by establishing operations in Malaysia. The...
Series A funding fuels May Mobility’s momentum
Millennium New Horizons and Cyrus Capital Partners have joined May Mobility’s...
ZAF Energy Systems Lands Strategic Investment from Wirtz...
Wirtz Manufacturing has made a strategic investment in battery developer ZAF Energy Systems...
Johnson & Johnson to acquire Auris Health for $3.4 billion
Johnson & Johnson says that its subsidiary, Ethicon, Inc., has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire surgical robotics company Auris Health, Inc. for approximately USD 3.4 billion in cash.
ZF plans to open new Serbian facility in April
German automotive technology company, ZF Friedrichshafen, is reportedly planning to open its...
Microlease and Electro Rent Europe to join forces
The two companies will unify their European operations to become one of the largest...
OHB awarded ESA contract for the development of...
OHB System AG, a subsidiary of the space and technology group OHB SE, has received funding...
Invotec expands its presence with new facility in Germany
Custom equipment provider Invotec is opening a facility in Villingen-Schwenningen...
WH executive order outlines AI plan, omits critical funding details
President Trump has signed an executive order creating the “American AI Initiative,” which serves as a high-level strategy guiding AI development within the U.S.
AIStorm snags USD 13.2 million in quest to advance edge processing
San Jose-based AI start-up AIStorm has secured USD 13.2 million in Series A financing from...
Related news
Most Read
Load more news