© Analog Devices Inc.
Application Notes | February 05, 2021
Orthogonal Perspectives
Question: I am using a MEMS inertial measurement unit (IMU) in a self-balancing guidance control system for a personal transportation platform. Can I expect a consumer targeted IMU to eliminate all misalignment errors between each sensor if all of the core sensor elements are on a single piece of silicon?
Answer:
No, this is generally not a safe expectation for your design. Industrial grade IMUs, which use robust discrete sensors with optimal packaging and caibration, offer much better alignment precision than consumer-targeted IMUs residing on a single piece of silicon.
Consumer targeted and industrial targeted IMUs tend to specify axis alignment behaviors differently. Consumer IMUs typically lump all misalignment errors into a single cross-axis sensitivity specification. Industrial targeted IMUs, such as the recently released ADIS16490, specify alignment precision more directly using two different specifications: axis-to-axis misalignment error and axis-to-package misalignment error. The axis-to-package misalignment error describes how well the alignment in each axis relates to mechanical features within the IMU package. Axis-to-axis misalignment error describes how well the alignment of each accelerometer and gyroscope axis fits into the ideal case of mutual orthogonality. This is why axis-to-axis misalignment error is also commonly known as orthogonal error.
We can see the mathematical relationship between cross-axis sensitivity (CAS) and axis-to-axis misalignment error (A2A_MAE) as described below:
CAS = sin(A2A_MAE)
A2A_MAE = asin(CAS)
The effect of nonorthogonality occurs between sensor axes, across sensors, or from package misalignment between the sensors and the enclosure. On an industrial targeted IMU, these specifications are fully described in the data sheet after factory calibration. For discrete components, the cross-axis sensitivity specification does not account for assembly variances to a PCB.
Ideally, multiple axes within gyroscopes and accelerometers are mutually orthogonal to each other. However, it is a common misconception that since a multi-axis gyroscope or accelerometer can be designed within one discrete MEMS component that each of the axes are perfectly orthogonal at 90° to one another. Although all inertial sensors in these devices are on a single piece of silicon, inherent errors introduced from fabrication and manufacturing variances can still accumulate an orthogonal error. The resulting equivalent alignment precision is actually not very impressive when compared to fully calibrated, industrial targeted IMUs.
A quick survey of consumer targeted devices reveals that cross-axis sensitivity is often in the range of 1% to 5%. Using the above relationship, that results in equivalent axis-to-axis misalignment errors of 0.57° to 2.87°. However, it could also be defined in units of milliradian, equal to 0.057°. Industrial grade IMUs will typically be much more precise. We can also use this relationship to translate the axis-to-axis misalignment error of an industrial targeted IMU of 0.018° into an equivalent cross-axis sensitivity of 0.031%.
CAS = sin(A2A_MAE) = sin(0.018°) = 0.00031 = 0.031%
Despite the apparent disadvantage of not having all inertial sensors on one piece of silicon, the ADIS16489 industrial grade IMU still offers ~32× better performance than the best consumer devices.
To understand the effect of nonorthogonal errors, let’s assume that one accelerometer axis is pointed perfectly upward and the device is exactly level. The accelerometer on this z-axis is ideally measuring the total impact of gravity. If the other two axes were perfectly orthogonal, they would not measure any vector of gravity.
However, if there is a nonorthogonality error, these two other horizontal axes would measure some portion of the gravity vector. For example, if a device offers a cross-axis sensitivity of 1%, its equivalent response to gravity will be 10 mg. This equates to an equivalent alignment error of 0.6°. Conversely,
if the first axis is not orthogonal to the level frame, it will measure less than the complete gravity vector.
Orthogonality errors are particularly stable components of the total error from an accelerometer. They may therefore yield to corrections based on a one time calibration. To determine the orthogonality error of accelerometer axis pairs, the static response of each axis to gravity is measured as the acceler-ometer is rotated through the space of all possible 90° orientations. This can be done using either a precision gimbal mount or on a known orthogonal surface.
It can be a challenging proposition to effectively calibrate out the orthogonal errors across the full operating conditions after mounting components onto a PCB. Inertial calibration requires observation of each sensor response, while the devices are experiencing well-controlled motion profiles. These types of motion profiles often require highly specialized equipment and expertise to operate effectively over time. In contrast to an industrial targeted IMU that is already precalibrated for mounting, each mounted consumer MEMS device on a PCB would need to be calibrated against the other sen-sors, environmental performance, and temperature.
Performance from an industrial IMU, composed of 3 gyroscope axes and 3 accelerometer axes, leverages a calibration step within manufacturing after discrete comp-onents are mounted on a mini-PCB in a rugged module. This single factory calibration identifies and compensates not only the nonorthogonality of the MEMS devices themselves, but also for any assembly related skew. This minimizes the errors associated with variances from assembly, cross-axis error, and temperature.
The ADIS16489 provides factory calibration that minimizes axis alignment errors within platform stabilization, navigation, or robotics applications. With a dig-ital tri-axis gyroscope and a tri-axis accelerometer, the ADIS16489 offers a mere ±0.018° axis-to-axis gyroscope misalignment error and ±0.035° accelerometer axis-to-axis error. In addition to the high performance sensor parameters, the ADIS16489 also provides a parylene coating as a moisture barrier for its internal circuitry.
Figure 1. An ideal 3-axis orthogonal case on the left reflects the true impact of a vector. A nonorthogonal error allows leakage of rotation or force to be seen across all axes.
Author: Ian Beavers [ian.beavers@analog.com] is a product engineering manager for the Automation Energy and Sensors Team at © Analog Devices (Greensboro, NC). He has worked for the company since 1999. Ian has over 19 years of experience in the semiconductor industry. Ian earned a bachelor’s degree in electrical engineering from North Carolina State University and an M.B.A. from the University of North Carolina at Greensboro.

Author: Ian Beavers [ian.beavers@analog.com] is a product engineering manager for the Automation Energy and Sensors Team at © Analog Devices (Greensboro, NC). He has worked for the company since 1999. Ian has over 19 years of experience in the semiconductor industry. Ian earned a bachelor’s degree in electrical engineering from North Carolina State University and an M.B.A. from the University of North Carolina at Greensboro.
Broadcom to acquire VMware for $61 billion
Semiconductor design company Broadcom Inc. will acquire all of the outstanding shares in VMware, in a transaction that values the enterprise software company at approximately USD 61 billion.
GlobalFoundries launches GF Labs
At its annual GF Technology Summit (GTS), GlobalFoundries announced the launch of GF Labs, a new program that extends the development horizon of differentiated semiconductor technology.
Sunway partners with BMF to develop next-gen antennas
Sunway Communication has partnered with Boston Micro Fabrication (BMF) to develop next generation antennas. The companies have opened a joint development lab in San Diego, California.
InnovationLab acquires flexible printed battery technology from Evonik
German printed electronics specialist, InnovationLab, has acquired the TAeTTOOz printable battery technology from Evonik.
Sponsored content by Fusion
Manufacturers Reassess their Supply Chains
Prevailing obstacles since the COVID-19 Pandemic in 2020 have manufacturers reassessing their supply chain strategies. The following major disruptions that occurred entering 2022 added to existing setbacks, or created new ones altogether:
Motorola secures chip supply with GlobalFoundries deal
The US semiconductor foundry has entered into a long-term agreement to safeguard the supply of chip solutions for Motorola Solutions' radios, which are widely used by public safety, critical infrastructure and enterprise organisations.
Nexperia and Kyocera to develop GaN automotive power modules
Nexperia and Kyocera AVX Components (Salzburg) GmbH, have entered into a partnership with a focus on power components – the companies aims to jointly developing GaN applications for electric vehicles.
Intel invests $700 million in new Oregon mega lab
The US chipmaker plans to invest more than USD 700 million for a 200,000 square-foot, research and development mega lab focused on data center technologies and addressing areas such as heating, cooling and water usage.
Sponsored content by Proval Service
Since 25 years your partner for SMT stencils and solder pallets.
25 years of experience makes Proval Service not just a supplier but your trustful and grounded partner to support you with SMT stencils and solder pallets. A qualified and unite team can satisfy every customer's need during the whole process.
Obsolescence management cannot be an afterthought
“Obsolescence has always existed. However, it usually only becomes really critical for companies when the exception mutates into the norm. And in recent years we have unfortunately experienced this unwanted development not only with semiconductor chips, but increasingly with many other components, materials and raw materials,” says IIOM President and COGD Chairman Dr Wolfgang Heinbach.
Tower record 1Q22 revenues of $421 Million, a 21% YoY
Tower Semiconductor reported first quarter 2022 revenue of USD 421 million, an increase of 21% compared to USD 347 million in the first quarter of 2021.
Gallium Semiconductor opens its Nijmegen R&D center
Gallium Semiconductor has officially held the grand opening of its European R&D center in a ceremony in Nijmegen, the Netherlands.
Ferrotec to add manufacturing capacity with new plant in Malaysia
Ferrotec, a global supplier of materials, components, and precision system solutions, is establishing a new manufacturing facility at Kulim Hi-Tech Park, Kedah, facilitated by the Malaysian Investment Development Authority (MIDA).
Skeleton targets the Polish market – teams up with ZPUE
Supercapacitor specialist, Skeleton Technologies, and ZPUE, a Polish manufacturer of electrical devices for electrical power distribution utilities, have entered into a commercial agreement to provide energy storage solutions to the Polish market.
ERP partners with Flip to fulfill EOL and Obsolete component solutions
Flip Electronics has signed a franchised distributor partnership agreement with ERP Power (ERP) to distribute its End-of Life (EOL) semiconductor products.
Foxconn and DNeX build and operate wafer fab in Malaysia
Dagang NeXchange Berhad (DNeX) and Foxconn subsidiary Big Innovation Holdings (BIH), plan to set up a joint venture company to build and operate a new 300mm wafer fab in Malaysia.
Imec and semiconductor partners target greener chip manufacturing
Nanoelectronics research and innovation center, imec, says that it has managed to pool together stakeholders from the semiconductor value chain – from companies such as Apple and Microsoft, to suppliers, including ASM, Kurita, SCREEN and Tokyo Electron – to participate in its Sustainable Semiconductor Technologies and Systems (SSTS) research program.
SiPearl reaches milestone – 100 employees
The European chip designer has exceeded 100 employees across its six sites in France (Maisons-Laffitte, Grenoble, Massy, Sophia Antipolis), Germany (Duisburg) and Spain (Barcelona).
Arrow names Jörg Strughold as president EMEA components
Arrow Electronics announces that Jörg Strughold will take over as president of its components business in EMEA. He succeeds Martin Bielesch who has decided to leave the company.
€14 billion to attract semiconductor players to Germany
EUR 14 billion in state support is the German governments new strategy to attract more chipmakers to the country.
10 different companies have expressed interest in Toshiba
Back in April 2022, Toshiba Corporation announced that it had resolved to solicit proposals on strategic alternatives from potential investors and sponsors. The Japanese company is seeking to enhance its corporate value and has since the announcement been holding discussions with the potential partners.
Avnet breaks ground on German expansion
In order to better serve its customers’ local and global needs, Avnet is expanding in two locations in Germany. Avnet Embedded broke ground on a new manufacturing site in Eschbach and Avnet EMEA plans to build its third European logistics centre in Bernburg.
Load more news