© Analog Devices Application Notes | December 11, 2020
Burned by Low Power? When lower current consumption can get you into trouble
Question: I changed one of my devices to a newer and better part with lower current consumption. Nothing is working anymore and even the new part got “burned.” Do you have any explanation?
Answer: Linear regulators are fairly simple devices and don’t have too many challenges. With that said, you can still get into trouble with them occasionally. In my role as a field applications engineer, there are times when customers request me to recommend a drop in replacement for a part they are using from another supplier. In many of these cases, the decision to replace a part is made by the customer’s production/purchase team and the original circuit designer may not be aware of the change. The decision process is fairly simple and the alternative part should have the same functionality, package, and pin configuration, as well as equal or better electrical specifications when compared to the device being replaced. Once all of these boxes are checked, you provide the necessary comparison data to the component engineer and the new component is added to the bill of materials as a second source alternative. After doing that, you should be all set. That is, until the product that was working faithfully with the older component starts failing on the production line after changing over to the alternative. What went wrong?! I was involved in one such case where we followed the previously mentioned process and got one of our isolated RS-485 transceivers designed in as a second source to another supplier’s device in a customer’s design. The devices were form, fit, and functionality compatible, and our part had better electrical specifications. The customer went ahead and ordered a large quantity of this part from us and there seemed no reason for anything to go wrong. However, the customer reported that the new RS-485 transceiver started failing on the production test bed. Since nothing else in the design had been changed, it came down to something being wrong with the new device in the picture. Upon further investigation, we found that the linear regulator powering the bus side of the transceiver was not regulating down to 5 V as expected, but instead was going up to a much higher voltage. We needed to do a careful review and comparison of the data sheets for the older transceiver and the replacement one, as well as the data sheet of the linear regulator to figure out what was going wrong. Better is a qualitative term and depends on the parameter in question. For example, when it comes to speed/CMRR/PSRR, higher is better; when it comes to offset voltage/drift, lower is better; and you don’t need great engineering insight to know that when it comes to power consumption, lower is always better. Or is it? In this particular case, it turned out it wasn’t. The older transceiver consumed 15 mA (typically) on the bus side in idle state, while the new device consumed only 2 mA (maximum). It was no wonder that the new device looked better on paper. Unfortunately, the linear regulator didn’t seem to agree and went berserk. As I mentioned at the start of this article, linear regulators are fairly simple devices that don’t have too many demands. Their one peculiar requirement is that they need a minimum load current to function properly. If this condition is not met, the regulator stops regulating correctly and the output voltage goes out of bounds. The situation could also get worse if the input voltage to the regulator is much higher than the desired output voltage. Read this excellent article for more details on this topic.1 Many modern linear regulators take special care in their design to address this and pose no such problems. Some of the older devices (like the one in the customer’s design) don’t, and, hence, need extra precautions during the system design. In some cases, the feedback resistor network for the adjustable output LDO takes care of the minimum load current. Unfortunately, one could run into this issue inadvertently by deciding to supersize these resistors while keeping the ratio the same. There could also be another scenario in which the device being powered by the LDO meets the load requirement during normal operation, but not while it’s in standby. These are all potential pitfalls to watch out for, so be sure to read the LDO data sheet carefully. If there’s a minimum load current requirement, it would usually say so in some way. Here are a couple of examples: Figure 1. An example of a minimum load current from a data sheet. Figure 2. Left schematic: the regulator operating correctly with the older device (minimum load current requirement satisfied). Right schematic: the unstable regulator with the new device (load current not sufficient).
Images and graphs: © Analog Devices Inc.
Figure 3. The problem resolved after adding a bleeder resistor to draw minimum required load current.Going back to our story—once the root cause of the problem was understood, it was fairly simple to fix. All we had to do was add a bleeder resistor on the regulator output to draw the minimum load current. While it would have been easy for an unreasonable customer to blame it on our part, this particular customer could see the funny side of this story and was able to appreciate the technical learning from this episode. It all ended well like any fairy tale—a little blood was spilled, but everyone lived happily ever after. References 1. Luca Vassalli. “Minimum Load Current Operation—Zero-Load Operation.” Analog Dialogue, Vol 48, September, 2014.
Images and graphs: © Analog Devices Inc.
Murata completes new Okayama production building The Japanese company’s production subsidiary, Okayama Murata Manufacturing, initiated an expansion of its operations in Setouchi City with a new production building in December 2019. Now the building stands complete.
Osram signs supply and commercial agreement with LeddarTech ADAS and AD sensing specialist, LeddarTech, and automotive lighting and laser systems supplier Osram, have entered into a long-term agreement.
Sponsored content by Shenzen Kinwong ElectronicThe development trend of printed circuit board products and Kinwong's solution With the rapid development of electronic technology in recent years, printed circuit board (PCB) products are pursuing higher heat dissipation capabilities, with high voltage and high current characteristics, and are developing towards high-density interconnection technology (HDI).
ITW to acquire MTS Test & Simulation business From Amphenol Illinois Tool Works Inc., a global multi-industrial manufacturing company, and the provider interconnect, antenna and sensor solutions, Amphenol Corporation, have entered into an agreement under which ITW will acquire MTS Systems Corporation’s Test & Simulation business, following the closing of Amphenol’s acquisition of MTS.
Tobey Gonnerman named Fusion Worldwide's new President The global sourcing distributor announces that Tobey Gonnerman has been appointed as the company’s new President.
Solving the Cable TV Infrastructure Downstream Transmitter Challenge Driven by demand for faster internet connectivity, the cable TV industry has developed new network architectures for the delivery of multigigabit services to subscribers. This fiber deep approach, using a remote PHY device (RPD), moves critical hardware closer to the users by using digital fiber.
Boyd expands its footprint with new facility in Mexico Thermal management and engineered material solutions specialist Boyd Corporation, has expanded its presence in North America with a newly built facility strategically located in Juarez, Mexico.
Farnell becomes a global distribution partner NI the distributor of electronic components, products and solutions has been appointed as an NI Authorized Distributor, expanding its product portfolio to include NI software-connected test and measurement solutions for customers of all sizes.
Foxconn and Winbond invest in chipmaker Kneron Foxconn and Winbond joins companies such as Qualcomm, Horizons, Sequoia and Weltrend as high profile investors in Kneron
EV Group sets up customer training facility at HQ EV Group (EVG) has established the EVG Academy, a training facility for customers that provides technical training on all classes of the company's equipment as well as on its CIM Framework software platform in an optimised environment.
Denso team up with Aeva to develop sensing and perception systems Mobility supplier Denso says that it is partnering with U.S. LiDAR and perception systems company, Aeva, to develop next-generation sensing and perception systems.
Fire hit Taiwanese MLCC manufacturer in China On January 13 a fire broke out at Taiwanese passive component maker Walsin Technology’s Dongguan, China site.
Thin Film Products joins SERMA Microelectronics SERMA Microelectronics, a subsidiary of the French electronics specialist SERMA Group, has finalised the purchase of TFP (Thin Film Products), a French manufacturer of thin-film microwave circuits for space, military and civil applications.
New Korean Zestron Technical Center opens for customers The provider of high precision cleaning products has expanded its operations by opening a new Technical Center, located in Anyang, Korea.
A2 Global Electronics names new executives Electronic component distribution and supply chain service provider, A2 Global Electronics, has appointed Anthony Andriano as its new Chief Financial Officer and promoted Jesper Romell as its new President.
ROHM expands production capacity of SiC power devices ROHM has recently held an opening ceremony announcing the completion of a new building at ROHM Apollo's Chikugo plant, which the company started building back in February 2019, to enhance the production capacity of SiC power devices.
Elmos acquires Online Engineering GmbH Elmos is strengthening its in-house competencies in software engineering via the acquisition of Dortmund based engineering service provider Online Engineering.
Plasmatreat expands with new subsidiary in Switzerland The technology company says it has further developed its international proximity to its customers by founding its new subsidiary Plasmatreat Schweiz AG, and thus taking steps to better serve the Swiss market.
RAFI Group increases their presence on the Nordic market The RAFI Group, a specialist of human–machine interaction and EMS, increases their presence on the Nordic market in 2021. Stefan Steiner has been named the RAFI sales manager for the Nordic operations located in Stockholm.
Filtronic wins new UK defence contract UK designer and manufacturer of antennas, filters and mmWave products, Filtronic plc, has won a significant contract from a new major UK defence customer for the supply of battlefield radio communications hardware valued at over GBP 1 million.
A2 Global expands with new facility in Singapore Electronic component distribution and supply chain service provider, A2 Global Electronics, announces the opening of its new distribution facility located in the New Tech Park area of Singapore.
Sensata acquires majority ownership of Lithium Balance Sensata, an industrial technology company that develops sensors and sensor-based solutions, has acquired 75% of Lithium Balance based in Denmark.
Analog Devices to shutter California facility In a WARN notice, the company says that due to changing business needs will require the company to permanently close its facility Milpitas, California.
Intelliconnect moves to larger factory as sales grow Intelliconnect (Europe) Ltd the UK based specialist manufacturer of RF, waterproof and cryogenic connectors and cable assemblies, announces that it has moved to a larger facility at the Corby Innovation Hub following sales growth of 30% in 2020.
Pat Gelsinger to replace Bob Swan as Intel CEO Intel has appointed 40-year technology industry veteran Pat Gelsinger as its new chief executive officer, effective February 15, 2021. He will succeed Bob Swan, who will remain CEO until Pat starts.
Qualcomm to acquire NUVIA Qualcomm says it has entered into a definitive agreement to acquire NUVIA for approximately USD 1.4 billion before working capital and other adjustments.
Advanced Energy acquires RF specialist Advanced Energy, a provider of precision power conversion, measurement, and control solutions, has completed the acquisition of Versatile Power, a Campbell, California-based provider of radio frequency (RF) and programmable power supplies for medical and industrial applications.Load more news