© tom_schmucker dreamstime.com Business | April 15, 2019
The “meat” of Qualcomm’s business model on trial in San Diego
Apple Inc. and its allies square off in a jury trial today against chip supplier Qualcomm Inc. The trial, taking place in San Diego, seeks to determine whether Qualcomm has engaged in illegal patent licensing practices. The plaintiffs are seeking up to USD 27 billion in damages.
In a story filed by Reuters on Friday, and reported on previously in various media outlets, Qualcomm is alleging that Apple forced its longtime business partners to quit paying some royalties and is seeking up to USD 15 billion. Filed in federal court by Apple in early 2017, the lawsuit focuses on the modem chips that connect devices like the iPhone or Apple Watch to wireless data networks. Qualcomm has spent the past two years mounting a pressure campaign of smaller legal skirmishes against Apple, seekingꟷand in some cases winningꟷiPhone sales bans for violating its patents. For Apple, the trial is about the freedom to determine its own technology path for blockbuster products by buying chips without having to pay what it calls a “tax” on its innovations in the form of patent licensing fees to Qualcomm that take a cut of the selling price of its devices. For Qualcomm, the trial, along with similar allegations from U.S. regulators in a January court hearing, will determine the fate of its unique practice of mixing the sale of chips and licensing more than 130,000 patents. Gaston Kroub, a patent attorney with Kroub, Silbersher & Kolmykov, who is not involved in the case, told Reuters, “This is the day of reckoning that Qualcomm has been very fortunate to avoid for many years. In Apple, they’ve finally come up against a potential licensee that has the resources and the will to put Qualcomm’s business model and licensing practices on trial.” At center is Qualcomm’s practice that requires device makers to sign a patents license before it will supply chips, which it views as a commonsense measure to ensure it does not do business with companies violating its patents. Apple and other companies have called the “no license, no chips” policy a form of “double dipping.” In other words, Qualcomm is charging for the same intellectual property once during licensing discussions, and then again in the price of the chips where the patents manifest. Apple and allies are asking for an end to the double-dipping practice and a refund of about USD 9 billion, which may be tripled if the jury finds in Apple’s favor for antitrust allegations concerning contract factories such as Foxconn, who paid the royalties and were reimbursed by Apple. Apple alleges the practices kept Intel Corp. and other rivals like them out of the market for years. “Even very big companies like Intel have felt at a disadvantage,” said Michael Salzman, an antitrust attorney with Hughes Hubbard & Reed not involved in the case. Qualcomm’s position, according to the Reuters report, is that it has successful working relationships with contract factories prior to the release of the Apple iPhone. But Apple leveraged its strength in the industry to persuade factories to break their longstanding contracts with Qualcomm, which led to at least USD 7 billion in royalties lost, the chip supplier alleges. “I don’t think (a Qualcomm victory) would be great for Apple, but if it’s about money, they’ve got plenty of money,” said Stacy Rasgon, an equity analyst for Bernstein who follows Qualcomm. “For Qualcomm, it’s an existential attack on the meat of their business model.”
Walsin restarts production at resistor plant in Malaysia The manufacturer was forced to temporarily shut down production at the plant in late November to facilitate coronavirus-related inspections.
Siltronic moves into new HQ in Munich As we entered December, the German wafer manufacturer moved to its new headquarters in the Bavaria Towers in Munich, Germany.
Infineon plans to make Singapore its global AI innovation hub The German chip-giant is celebrating its 50th anniversary in Singapore announcing plans to make the country its AI innovation hub as it moves forward with its digital transformation.
Transphorm choses Veeco system for GaN-based power and 5G devices Veeco Instruments says that Transphorm, a supplier of gallium nitride (GaN) products for high voltage power conversion applications, has selected its Propel HVM MOCVD System for high-volume production of GaN-based RF (DoD and Commercial/5G) and power electronics Epiwafers.
TTI denies Chinese military ties by its Hong Kong subsidiary The specialty distributor is denying that it’s Hong Kong subsidiary has any ties to Chinese military following the Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) naming the Asian unit in a draft rule.
ECD Launches SelectiveRIDER™, Closes the Loop on Automated Soldering Solutions ECD announced the addition of SelectiveRIDER™ to its portfolio of soldering process measurement pallets, effectively closing the loop to deliver a complete line of automated verification technologies for every machine soldering process: wave, reflow and selective.
All That Glitters Is Not Gold! Application engineers often repeatedly answer the same questions from different customers, especially queries related to the selection of parts in their application. One mistake we see in part selection happening time and time again is that the customers become over enamored by what I like to call “the sheet” in data sheets.
Infineon extends franchise sales agreement with Future Electronics Future Electronics can now sell both the Infineon and the Cypress portfolios of products to customers across the Europe, Americas and Asia regions
Private equity firm acquires Evans Capacitor Company Arcline Investment Management has acquired the Rhode Island based manufacturer of high energy density capacitors.
Diodes completes its acquisition of Lite-On Semiconductor Diodes Incorporated has completed its close to USD 450 million acquisition of Lite-On Semiconductor (LSC).
Toshiba says it's not negotiating with UMC Toshiba Electronic Devices & Storage Corporation states that despite certain media reports, the company is not selling two of its fabs to Taiwanese United Microelectronics Corporation.
NVIDIA acquires Swedish VCSEL startup On the heels of the GPU-giant’s massive USD 40 billion acquisition of ARM – which was just made official back in September – comes yet another acquisition; though this time at a much smaller scale.
Analog Devices ends its fiscal year 2020 on a high Fourth quarter revenue came in at USD 1.53 billion, above the high-end of the company’s outlook.
GlobalWafers confirms takeover discussions with Siltronic The Taiwanese company says it is in advanced, near to final discussions on a takeover offer of German supplier of silicon wafers, Siltronic AG.
Covid-19 halts Chinese SK Hynix plant The discovery of an asymptomatic, but infected, employee brought SK Hynix’s plant in Chongqing, China to a halt on Sunday.
Murata to shut down Chinese production facility Saitama Murata Manufacturing, a subsidiary of Murata, will close its its coil production subsidiary Sheng Long TOKO Tech, located in Shenzhen, China, during December 2020
Antistat™ launch new product range of ESD Anti-fatigue matting Manufactured in the EU, Antistat’s new range of matting blends exceptional quality with durability offering a life span of up to 5 years.
Digi-Key inks new U.S. distribution partnership with MISCO Digi-Key Electronics has expanded its product portfolio to include a U.S. distribution partnership with MISCO, a resource offering complete audio solution services.
Arkema kickstarts capacity increase of fluoropolymer in China Arkema is starting up its 50% capacity increase of Kynar fluoropolymer for the lithium-ion battery business at its Changshu plant in China in December 2020, with the first commercial supplies for January 2021.
STMicro and YTO set up joint lab for smart agricultural equipment Semiconductor manufacturer STMicroelectronis, is teaming up with Chinese provider of agricultural and construction machinery YTO Group to establish a joint lab which will focus on R&D of electronic solutions for engine, vehicle, and agricultural controls in tractors.
12 new 1200V Hyperfast and Ultrafast Rectifiers from Vishay New Yorker Electronics has announced the availability of 12 new FRED Pt® Gen 5 1200 V Hyperfast and Ultrafast rectifiers from Vishay Semiconductor. The ideal choice for soft switched and resonant high frequency converters, it features a unique combination of low conduction and switching losses.
SKT's new AI chip changes the company's AI semiconductor business vision SK Telecom (SKT) has unveiled its new, self-developed, AI chip named SAPEON X220; a chip that, according to the company, will alter the company's AI semiconductor business vision.Load more news